Sen. Kamala Harris announced her version of Medicare-for-All on Monday, and in so doing reshaped her stance on one of the more divisive issues of the Democratic presidential primary with a plan that would allow those who want to keep their private coverage to do so, provided those insurers offer plans that adhere to the same regulations as the government-offered Medicare option.
The plan represents a pivot for Ms. Harris, who has previously said she supported Sen. Bernie Sanders’ Medicare-for-All bill, which would effectively eliminate the private health insurance market.
“This isn’t about pursuing an ideology,” Ms. Harris wrote in a Medium post she published Monday to outline the plan. “This is about delivering for the American people.”
She previously suggested that private insurance should exist only to cover supplemental expenses, such as cosmetic surgery, foreign travel insurance and other things not covered under Medicare. But as she has throughout her campaign, Ms. Harris is arguing for a more expansive Medicare plan than many of her competitors have proposed previously, one that would reduce the need for supplemental insurance by extending coverage to vision, dental, hearing aids and mental health services. An aide to her campaign said Ms. Harris is trying to “respond to the concerns and anxieties” she has heard on the trail.
Many voters at Ms. Harris events have spoken about being forced to give up their private plans in favor of a public one. In Iowa, multiple voters asked Ms. Harris about the jobs that would be lost in the private insurance sector should Medicare-for-All mandate public coverage. Under the terms of her plan, voters would not have to give up their private insurer as long as that insurer offers a plan that meets Medicare regulations, like Medicare Advantage does for seniors now. The plan also would allay concerns about the loss of jobs in private insurance, which could continue to exist.
“Seniors will be able to keep their Medicare and have dental, vision, and hearing aids covered immediately. Medicare Advantage plans would continue uninterrupted by the transition,” Ms. Harris wrote in the Medium post. “Under my plan, no one will lose access to insurance during a transition. Period.”
Read More
Ms. Harris’ plan is based on Mr. Sanders’ Medicare-for-All Bill - a measure she has signed - which calls for a complete transition to a government-run insurance plan over four years, but differs in three major ways.
First, Ms. Harris’ bill would not force a transition to a public Medicare-for-All option, but would allow private insurers to continue offering plans provided they adhere to “strict requirements to ensure it lowers costs and expands services.”
“If [private insurers] want to play by our rules, they can be in the system,” Ms. Harris wrote in the post. “If not, they have to get out.”
As soon as the plan is passed, anyone who wants it would be able to buy in to Medicare, a similar setup to the immediate buy-in Mr. Sanders outlines. All newborns and uninsured Americans would be enrolled immediately. Ms. Harris also wrote that, after passing the bill, her administration would “provide a commonsense path for employers, employees, the underinsured, and others on federally-designated programs, such as Medicaid or the Affordable Care Act exchanges, to transition.”
Second, Ms. Harris’ bill would extend the transition period from four to 10 years, providing for what she says would be a less expensive transition than one carried out over a shorter period.
Third, Ms. Harris’ plan calls for a less-substantial middle-class tax increase than Mr. Sanders’ does. Mr. Sanders’ bill would fund Medicare-for-All with a 4 percent tax increase on all Americans making more than $29,000 annually. Ms. Harris would raise that threshold to $100,000, and pay for the difference with a 0.2 percent tax on all stock trades, a 0.1 percent tax on all bond trades, and a .002 percent tax on derivative transactions. She also would tax offshore corporate income at the same rate as domestic corporate income, proposals she says would raise more than $2 trillion over 10 years - enough to make up for the money lost by not raising taxes on those making $29,000 to $100,000.
Ms. Harris’ “plans to ensure that Wall Street and multinational corporations are paying their fair share of taxes are both good ideas,” said Michael Linden, a former policy adviser to Senate HELP and Budget Committees and economy policy director of the Center for American Progress, who agreed to speak on behalf of the plan for the campaign.
They “would generate enough revenue to offset her proposal’s higher income threshold after which premium payments begin - $100,000 rather than $29,000 - which is intended to help the middle class.”
While Ms. Harris has signed on to a variety of health-care reform bills over the years - including Sen. Michael Bennet’s Medicare X bill, which would create a public option - she will now have to account for her shifting outlook about private insurance. In her first CNN town hall appearance, Ms. Harris was asked about the bureaucracy and shortcomings of private insurance and said, “Let’s do away with all that.” She later clarified her stance to explain that her vision of Medicare-for-All would allow private insurance for supplemental health concerns.
Later, at the first Democratic debates last month, Ms. Harris and Mr. Sanders were the only candidates to raise their hands when asked whether they would abolish private insurance. Ms. Harris later said she misheard the question, and thought she was answering the question of whether she would give up her own private insurance in favor of Medicare-for-All. Ms. Harris has often expressed frustration with questions suggesting that she has altered her positions, and the Medium post Monday accounted for the notion that she has not always been able to articulate her position in an easy-to-digest format.
“One of the problems with our politics is that it often demands 60-second sound bites or slogans to answer complex questions,” she wrote. “There is perhaps no more complicated or more personal issue for Americans than health care.”
The timing of Ms. Harris’ plan was calculated, giving her a distinct position on a so-far confounding issue just in time for the second Democratic debates, which will take place this week in Detroit. In recent weeks, former Vice President Joe Biden, a Democratic presidential rival, accused Ms. Harris of wanting to do away with the Affordable Care Act as part of her support of Medicare-for-All. Ms. Harris has argued that she was a staunch defender of the Affordable Care Act in the face of Republican challenges, and that her plan is simply building on former President Barack Obama’s plan. Ms. Harris and Mr. Biden will stand next to each other in the center of the stage Wednesday night.
Few rushed to align themselves with the Harris proposal.
A top adviser to Mr. Biden, with whom Ms. Harris memorably clashed during the first debate, blasted the California senator’s plan as a failed attempt to please all sides in the debate and warned that her decision to push a 10-year transition obscures the full cost of her approach.
“This new, have-it-every-which-way approach pushes the extremely challenging implementation of the Medicare for All part of this plan ten years into the future, meaning it would not occur on the watch of even a two-term administration,” said Mr. Biden’s deputy campaign manager, Kate Bedingfield. “The result? A Bernie Sanders-lite Medicare for All and a refusal to be straight with the American middle class, who would have a large tax increase forced on them with this plan.”
Ms. Harris also got hit from the left over her health care tightrope walk. Sanders campaign manager Faiz Shakir accused her of “continuing her gradual backdown from Medicare for All” and suggested that she had been inconsistent on the issue of health care.
Adam Gaffney, the president of Physicians for a National Health Program, said Ms. Harris’ plan has “several major shortcomings,” including the continuation of private insurance and the longer transition period.
“This plan continues to give private insurance a very central role in the health care system,” he said. “We have seen for decades that that does not work.”
But Topher Spiro, vice president for health policy at the left-leaning think tank Center for American Progress, lauded Ms. Harris for trying to assuage “concerns that people have about disruption and about an abrupt transition” away from a largely employer-based health insurance system.
Mr. Spiro likened Ms. Harris’ plan to the current design of Medicare and Medicaid, which he said “shows it’s possible to have a government program that provides benefits through private options that is very cost-efficient.” He declined to say whether he consulted with the campaign on its plan beyond providing information on Medicare Extra, his group’s proposed alternative to Mr. Sanders’ Medicare-for-All.
The Associated Press contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.