Cancer patient on Highmark UPMC split

Like thousands of other people with Highmark health insurance, Gary and Paula Brant of Mt. Lebanon have reason to worry about the pending breakup of Pittsburgh’s two health care giants.

Ms. Brant, 61, a retired self-employed business owner, has been treated at UPMC’s Hillman Cancer Center for lung cancer for more than five years. She was physically active before the diagnosis and never smoked, numbering among the 10 percent to 15 percent of lung cancer patients with no history of smoking.

Now, the end of contractual relations between Highmark and UPMC on June 30 means the Brants face the prospect of having to find new doctors when the Hillman center is no longer covered by the couple’s insurance network.

Unlike other Highmark members who are treated by UPMC doctors and have similar concerns, the Brants have an advantage:

Advertise with us

Mr. Brant owns a structured settlement company in Cranberry Township. He plans to drop Highmark insurance in April in favor of carrying UPMC Health Plan for himself and five employees — allowing his wife to continue treatment at Hillman.

Even as Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network ramps up construction of cancer treatment centers and hospitals, some of its members believe UPMC offers some medical services that aren’t yet available at AHN — raising the prospect of them having to switch health insurers or travel outside the city for specialized care.

Ms. Brant plans to stay with her UPMC oncologist after switching insurance, but the couple is not completely happy about the fix that Mr. Brant says will likely mean higher premiums.

“I worry about the folks who don’t have the option we have,” said Mr. Brant, president of Cranberry Township-based Brant Hickey & Associates. “It’s just crazy they’re fighting over this stuff.”

His concerns have been echoed by other Highmark insurance members at public meetings conducted by Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner in recent weeks. Also, in a legal action filed Feb. 7 in Commonwealth Court, state Attorney General Josh Shapiro accused UPMC of violating the charities law by restricting access to its hospitals based on the patient’s health insurance.

Advertise with us

In a prepared statement released when the legal action was taken, UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said the five-year wind down of the agreements between Highmark and UPMC has given consumers adequate opportunity to find other doctors or to switch insurers.

He also said consumers have benefited from the heightened competition that developed when UPMC opened its network of hospitals and doctors to commercial insurers, including companies like Aetna and United Healthcare that offer access to both Highmark and UPMC networks.

If nothing else, the June 30 end of the consent decrees has brought a spike in concerns from business owners about health care benefits, said Jessica Brooks, executive director of the Pittsburgh Business Group on Health.

“Right now, it’s a top of mind concern,” Ms. Brooks said. “It’s just causing a lot of stress.”

Highmark provides health insurance for 52 percent of the PIttsburgh Business Group on Health’s 98 employer members and among their concerns is whether patients will have to travel outside Pittsburgh after June 30 to receive specialized medical care if UPMC doctors are out of network.

Advertise with us

HIghmark spokesman Aaron Billger said the insurer’s members will continue to have access to UPMC for a variety of specialty medical services after June 30, including cystic fibrosis care, heart-lung transplant, lung transplant, live liver donor transplant and small bowel transplant.

Some kinds of minimally invasive eye surgery are available only at UPMC, which may be an out-of-network service when the consent decrees run out.

Ms. Brant notes that being forced to find a new doctor can be a painful experience.

The doctor-patient relationship is like a marriage, she said. “When you have a terminal disease and you have to suddenly change to a whole new set of doctors, it’s traumatic.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699