Hospitals began posting sticker prices for various procedures Tuesday in a bid to help patients become smarter shoppers in choosing medical care.
But critics say the new flood of data, which is mandated by the Affordable Care Act, will do little to help consumers in comparative shopping for x-rays, blood work and other procedures. The hospital charges are list prices and rarely reflect the actual amount consumers are billed unless they are without health insurance.
“It’s not what we really need,” said William Hennessey, founder and CEO of Greensburg-based medical billing analyst Pratter Inc. “The health care consumers deserve to know the price before they buy it and chances are that’s not the number they’re going to pay.”
Posting hospital charges adds to a number of other medical cost estimators that have been offered by insurers and others for years, including the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ Hospital Compare website. St. Clair Hospital in Mt. Lebanon rolled out an online calculator in 2016, which allows patients to estimate the out-of-pocket expense of their care based on their health plan. Washington Health System began offering patients an online cost estimating tool in December.
And Aetna, Highmark and UPMC Health Plan are among the carriers with tools to estimate medical costs.
To comply with the new rule, Greensburg-based Excela Health posted list prices for 6,300 procedures — ranging from surgical screws and drill bits to operating room staplers — but a spokeswoman said the format would likely change to better serve consumers in the future. A searchable tool is among the options.
“We have a list for consumers to see prices,” she said. “Will it look differently down the road? I’m certain it will.”
Critics of disclosing hospital charge information include Washington Health System, which said that sticker prices are likely just to confuse patients.
“In our opinion, providing a list of charges as required by CMS is missing the mark, which creates confusion for our patients,” the health system notes on its website.
Pittsburgh-based health system giant UPMC dismissed the listing of charges, saying patients were unlikely to benefit.
“It is highly unlikely that this will provide any meaningful information that would be useful for patients,” spokeswoman Susan Manko said in an email. “It is important to understand that the standard charge is not the amount that a patient is expected to pay for receiving health care services.”
In addition to people without health insurance, the move to list hospital charges was intended to help consumers who have high-deductible health plans — a group that has been shrinking in recent years, according to a survey by the National Business Group on Health.
High-deductible plans typically require large out-of-pocket contributions to health care expenses before coverage kicks in, so pricing transparency was expected to encourage shopping around.
It didn’t work out that way, partly because medical treatment is often unplanned and because workers found the price-comparison tools difficult to use.
High-deductible plans “didn’t really do what employers hoped they would do, which is create more sophisticated consumers of health care,” National Business Group on Health CEO Brian Marcotte told Kaiser Health News. “The health care system is just way too complex.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963; Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.