After 2,615 days — nearly twice as long as that more widely known civil war fought in the 1860s — UPMC and Highmark will officially go their separate ways on July 1, 2019.

The question is: Who will notice?

“A lot of the transition work has already been done. We believe we have prepared our members,” said Tom Fitzpatrick, Highmark senior vice president, last week. “We expect this is going to be a non-event.”

“I think both sides have moved beyond the point where Highmark says there has to be a contract,” offered UPMC spokesman Paul Wood. “The market has pretty much adapted.”

Advertise with us

One year out, the pending Highmark-UPMC split does not appear as scary as it did on May 2, 2012, when then-Gov. Tom Corbett pushed the two parties to extend their in-network contract another two years.

Or even in June 2014 when state officials stepped in again, steering Highmark and UPMC to sign two near-identical five-year consent decrees spelling out how these two health giants who’d dominated the Pittsburgh health insurance market (Highmark) and ran most of the hospitals (UPMC) would break up.

The two sides talk weekly now — an improvement from the consent decree negotiations during which Highmark and UPMC officials did not sit in the same room as state officials shuttle-mediated the agreements.

The conversations today are all business, sorting out the remaining details of the divorce.

“I don’t think there will be a peaceful co-existence, unfortunately,” said Mr. Fitzpatrick.

Advertise with us

Still, it could have been so much worse.

Predictions the past seven years have swung from the dire to the disbelieving: Some foresaw hundreds of patients wrenched from longtime, suddenly-out-of-network doctors while others remained certain the two would reach some last-minute agreement.

Robert Morris University professor and former hospital administrator Stephen Foreman includes himself in the latter group.

“I figured these people would stop fighting, and, boy, that sure hasn’t happened,” he said last week. “Instead they’ve taken the fight statewide.”

But most people appear to have made their choices by now, whether it involved changing doctors and hospital networks or changing health insurance plans. Locally, the fight now is for subscribers’ hearts, minds and premiums.

Advertise with us

The two organizations’ strategies could hardly be more different: Highmark emphasizes its “value-based” care, bringing medical services into the community so people get the right care in the right venue at the right time.

“We’re pretty tenacious competitors,” said Mr. Fitzpatrick. “We’re going to win on the field.”

UPMC, meanwhile, offers its global reputation for cutting-edge research and medical care, and some of the lowest cost individual marketplace plans anywhere.

Mr. Wood said increased competition among insurers in the commercial and government plan sectors, too, has helped keep insurance costs here in check. “We went from one of the most highly concentrated and least competitive markets in the nation to one that’s probably one of the more competitive and pro-consumer markets in the nation, offering some extremely low-cost health plans.”

Each side already has its individual victories to declare.

Advertise with us

“Virtually every employer is offering their employees a way to get to UPMC, either by offering UPMC Health Plan alongside of Highmark, or offering a national insurer alongside with Highmark, or replacing Highmark with UPMC Health Plan or a national insurer,” said Mr. Wood.

“We’re seeing that across the board.”

Mr. Fitzpatrick, though, said Highmark enjoys 94-95 percent subscriber retention rates, “higher than they’ve ever been.”

Its provider arm is finding its financial footing, too.

In December 2011, the auditing firm KPMG raised doubts that the core hospitals now comprising Allegheny Health Network, known then as West Penn Allegheny Health System, could survive. After multiple financial infusions from Highmark Health, AHN recently reported a positive $1.5 million operating income in the first quarter this year.

Advertise with us

Over the next five years, UPMC plans to spend $2 billion to build three world-class specialty hospitals inside Pittsburgh city limits while AHN dots the region with a network of five neighborhood hospitals, part of its $700 million plans for construction, expansion and renovation throughout its network.

Those plans cement the roles of both entities as critically important players to the region, providing both access to care and thousands of jobs. “We can’t afford to have either one go under,” said Mr. Foreman, a health care administration professor at RMU.

But he does worry about the attached cost, both for construction and as a result of having two systems offering duplicative services, sometimes within blocks of each other.

“They’ve invested so much money in this competition,” he said. “The thing I’m worried about is the sort of collective effect over time. Are we going to continue to see the capital investment we’re seeing?”

At some point, he said, that’s bound to be reflected in higher premiums for consumers.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.