Picture for a moment this unsettling scenario:

Some time after June 30, 2019, when Highmark and UPMC have finally gone their separate ways, a Highmark-insured pedestrian is seriously injured and unconscious after being struck by a car while crossing Fifth Avenue in Oakland.

Under federal law, UPMC Presbyterian — as the closest emergency room — is required to provide medical treatment until the person is stabilized and either transferred or sent home.

What the law does not require is that UPMC offer that service at a discounted rate.

Advertise with us

Billing at a higher rate for out-of-network care is a common, industry-wide practice that generally comes into play when someone needs emergency medical treatment while vacationing out of the area. But in this setting, it holds its own broad — and potentially costly — implications for Highmark members in the Pittsburgh region, where a majority of the emergency rooms are in UPMC hospitals.

Unless Highmark and UPMC come to terms, that life-saving care could have a devastating impact on a patient’s life savings.

So far, the two Pittsburgh health giants don’t even agree on how the process works.

UPMC spokesman Paul Wood says when an out-of-network patient is treated at one of the health system’s hospitals, “We charge the insurance company at the out-of-network rate.” In the scenario above, Highmark would be billed the same as Florida Blue Cross Blue Shield would be if one of its members received care at UPMC, he said.

“The insurance company reimburses us for the charges and then the insurance company decides what part of the charge is going to be the member’s responsibility.”

Advertise with us

Highmark, on the other hand, maintains that if a Highmark member receives emergency care at an out-of-network hospital, the provider — in this case UPMC — would bill the patient directly and Highmark would send the patient a check for the portion of the bill that it covers.

It then would be up to UPMC to decide what it will collect from the patient, said Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger.

Mr. Billger said Highmark has proposed an out-of-network reimbursement rate for its members’ emergency care that would prevent any balance billing of patients, but it has not yet received a response from UPMC.

Mr. Wood said, “UPMC is in regular contact with Highmark, but we don't publicly discuss negotiations.”

Highmark Health’s Allegheny Health Network hospitals do have an agreement with UPMC Health Plan on reimbursement for out-of-network emergency care provided for UPMC insurance members. Those patients are not billed for any balance.

Advertise with us

Kristine Grow, spokeswoman for America’s Health Insurance Plans in Washington, D.C., said the general industry practice is that nonparticipating hospitals and other providers will bill the insurer “almost as a courtesy to the patient.”

“However, they usually explain to the patient that, as they do not accept [that] insurance, they may not necessarily accept the level of insurance reimbursement as payment in full.”

UPMC has eight local hospitals with emergency departments compared to five in Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network. AHN does plan to include emergency departments in its planned four “neighborhood hospitals” and its 160-bed hospital in Pine.

Still, a Highmark member ending up in a UPMC emergency room is not an unlikely occurrence.

And those bills can be hefty.

Advertise with us

“Hospitals tend to mark up prices in the emergency department more than other departments because nobody really looks at the markup,” said Gerard Anderson, director for the Center for Hospital Finance and Management at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health in Baltimore.

“If you’re in an out-of-network system, you’re going to pay a very high markup for your emergency care, generally 5-8 times what it costs the hospital to provide the service.”

While health systems do not typically disclose their charges, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, or CMS, offers a glimpse its inpatient charge data report of how wide ranging those charges can be:

For fiscal 2015, the most recent data available, CMS listed UPMC Presbyterian Shadyside’s charge for treating someone with an intracranial hemorrhage with complications at $119,971.87. Medicare’s payment to the hospital, which more closely reflects the hospital’s actual cost, was $11,429.20.

Allegheny General’s charge was $71,561.99 (Medicare paid $11,815.44), and Heritage Valley Beaver’s charge was $16,324.75 (Medicare paid $7,599.25).

Advertise with us

Additional charges may come into play, Mr. Anderson said, because the treating emergency room physicians typically are out-of-network, too. “You’re going to get a double whammy.”

Insured patients getting in-network services will not pay full charges because their insurer has negotiated a reduced price as part of their plan’s benefits.

If Highmark and UPMC fail to reach an agreement, the out-of-network emergency care billing issue could once again be settled by a third party.

Both the state and courts have intervened in previous Highmark-UPMC disputes in the past seven years after Highmark announced plans to establish its own care provider network to compete with UPMC.

Most notably, then-Gov. Tom Corbett and state agency officials got the two sides to agree to the 2014 consent decrees as a framework for how UPMC and Highmark would transition away from each other over the ensuing five years.

Advertise with us

Earlier this month, Gov. Tom Wolf brokered an agreement between Highmark and UPMC regarding Highmark members’ access to some recently acquired UPMC hospitals in Central Pennsylvania and Pittsburgh-area specialty hospitals.

And just last week, Commonwealth Court Judge Dan Pellegrini presided over a separate Highmark-UPMC dispute about when Highmark’s nearly 50,000 Medicare Advantage members lose in-network access to UPMC physicians and hospital after the June 2019 expiration of the five-year consent decrees that map out how the UPMC-Highmark separation will unfold.

Whether state officials, the state legislature or state courts ultimately decide to weigh in on out-of-network emergency care billing remains to be seen but, whatever happens, health policy experts across the U.S. will be paying attention, Mr. Anderson said.

“This is a relatively unusual situation in Pittsburgh” with two health systems competing as both care providers and insurers in the same market, he said.

“You’re on the vanguard of doing this.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.