Five weeks after President Donald Trump pronounced Obamacare dead, saying, “You shouldn’t even mention it anymore,” at least 1.5 million people nationwide are betting that it’s still alive.
That’s the number who had signed up for a 2018 plan through Nov. 11, according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services — a faster enrollment pace than a year ago.
A key Pittsburgh-area navigator says her agency is seeing a similar trend.
“Yes, enrollments are up for this time period,” Lou Ann Jeremko, executive director of the Consumer Health Coalition on the North Side said this week. She said the service had 112 people enrolled the first week alone — a 17 percent spike from a year ago.
She credits a strong outreach effort, with staff calling clients who had enrolled last year to make appointments and setting up information booths at weekend events.
Whether the sign-up pace will continue, she can’t predict. “We do not know if this is the pattern we will see throughout the six weeks for an overall higher total or if it will drop off and we have the same number of enrollments for the year.”
It’s no surprise that Ms. Jeremko and others remain cautious about the Affordable Care Act’s fifth open enrollment period, now midway to its Dec. 15 terminus. Between the president’s declaration and the defunding of cost-sharing reduction subsidy payments so insurers will offer lower-cost plans, choosing a plan has become more perplexing than ever.
And that’s not taking into account the Republican Senate’s tax proposal that would drop the individual mandate requiring everyone to carry health insurance or face a penalty. If that happens, insurers likely will adjust rates upward — based on the expected exodus of the young and healthy from the risk pool.
That is, if insurers will remain in the ACA business at all.
Not all local ACA plan navigators are so far enjoying the coalition’s success, either. Melissa Borda, who helps people assess marketplace plans, said she saw her first client at North Side Christian Health Center on Wednesday — and he’s still undecided about signing up.
She thinks the president’s campaign against the health care plan is discouraging potential clients, although she acknowledged the center had only about five clients this time a year ago. “People don’t want to go through the effort to sign up if they’re not going to be guaranteed it’s going to be around.”
Adding to consumers’ confusion are letters that health plans sent to current enrollees this fall outlining their 2018 rates. Those showed monthly premiums ranging 20-30 percent higher based on the presumption the cost-sharing reduction payments will be gone.
“People are freaking out at those letters,” said Liz Kennon, who with her father, John, runs Kennon Insurance in Shadyside. The company specializes in individual and small group insurance.
She’s reminding her clients that under the still-living ACA, the higher premiums mean many will be eligible for higher tax credits as well.
“For most people with a steady income from year to year, I am seeing premiums for subsidy-eligible people go down,” Ms. Kennon said. “For those not getting subsidies, the premiums are going up about 17 percent to 50 percent depending on which plan they want to stick with in 2018.”
Even those people who aren’t in line for a tax credit may have good options, she said, as both UPMC Health Plan and Highmark are offering off-exchange plans that won’t show up on the ACA’s healthcare.gov website.
UPMC’s off-market-silver-plan carries a $267-$337 monthly premium for a 40-year-old non-smoker, with an $1,800 deductible and a yearly out-of-pocket maximum of $7,350.
Highmark’s two off-market plans for a 40-year-old nonsmoker have monthly premiums of about $400, with deductibles ranging from $2,850 to $3,750 and yearly out-of-pocket maximums of $6,550 and $7,350.
In short, pinning down the best plan for 2018 may involve some computation that might be both confusing and counterintuitive: Those who don’t qualify for subsidies may find a better option off the ACA market. And, with the defunding of subsidies, which largely impact midrange silver plans, some may find that more comprehensive gold plans have a lower premium.
Taken in toto, these factors may spur people to put in the extra time to get the best plan — or provide enough of a barrier that they either go elsewhere or go without.
It’s enough of an unknown that even Ms. Jeremko, who has been buoyed by the Health Coalition’s early enrollment surge, isn’t confident yet that the organization will meet its final enrollment projections.
“We won’t know until Dec. 17.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.