Pennsylvania could be one of the biggest losers in the Affordable Care Act replacement plan that squeaked through the House on Thursday, policy experts said, and for reasons that have gotten little public attention.
One example: Pennsylvania devotes more of its Medicaid spending to seniors and disabled people combined than almost anyplace else in the country. Care for these groups is especially costly, and the GOP plan would not keep pace with their needs. So Pennsylvania could be forced to cut benefits or raise taxes to maintain services that many people do not consider optional.
Health insurance premiums for people with pre-existing conditions also could rise more in Pennsylvania than nationally, said Antoinette Kraus, executive director of the Pennsylvania Health Access Network. A key compromise that led some of the most conservative Republicans to support the American Health Care Act is an optional waiver that allows states to let insurers charge sick applicants more than healthy ones.
The bill approved Thursday is expected to undergo major revisions in the Senate. Still, health-policy experts and health groups, including the American Medical Association, AARP, and others, expressed alarm.
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office has not yet projected the bill’s impact. It had estimated that an earlier version would leave 24 million more people uninsured by 2026.
Raymond Castro, director of health policy for New Jersey Policy Perspective, predicted that the Republican plan, if it becomes law, would put New Jersey and other states back on the path to a market death spiral. Even blue states might then be forced to ask permission to raise premiums for residents with pre-existing conditions, he said, because otherwise everyone’s insurance would be priced beyond reach.
Read More
Another part of the Republican plan changes the federal funding formula for Medicaid from an entitlement that rises along with costs to a cap that rises with enrollment but is capped below expected outlays. Because of the way it calculates changes in total Medicaid spending, states with more older and disabled beneficiaries would lose out.
A budget deficit in Harrisburg would make it hard for the state to make up for losses in federal funding.
“What do you do? Do you cut off categories of people? Do you reduce benefits? Increase cost sharing? Those are terrible Sophie’s Choices,” said Ann Torregrossa, executive director of the Pennsylvania Health Funders Collaborative and director of former Gov. Ed Rendell’s office of health-care reform.
She and others also pointed out that the Affordable Care Act stabilized finances for hospitals that had been operating on the edge, partly by covering patients who could not pay their bills.
“We’re eds and meds in this region,” Torregrossa said. “A great deal of employment and economic activity is based on what hospitals do. …. It’s not just about health-care coverage.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.