The Allegheny County Health Department has been turning up the heat on restaurants — posting more consumer alerts and closure orders when facilities break food safety rules — as part of an effort to better curb serious violations and crack down on repeat offenders.
The number of consumer alerts issued has tripled over the last two years — from 13 in 2014, to 27 in 2015 and then 47 last year. At the same time, the number of closure orders has more than doubled — from 17 in 2014 to 34 in 2015 to 37 last year.
The dramatic upswing doesn’t indicate restaurants in the Pittsburgh region are getting dirtier, county health department officials say.
Instead, it represents an increased effort to enforce safe food handling practices and prevent inspectors from having to re-visit restaurants multiple times before owners fix the most serious problems that put patrons at risk for food-borne illnesses.
“I don’t feel that restaurants are doing worse than they were before,” said Karen Hacker, who took over as director of the health department in September 2013. “This is a product of a department that has dramatically changed the way it is doing business.

PG graphic: A look at the enforcement statistics
(Click image for larger version)
“Before I got here,” Dr. Hacker said, “it was my understanding there wasn’t a lot of enforcement going on.”
Stricter enforcement comes in the wake of the county health department’s defeated plan to post A-B-C grades on restaurant doors based on results of annual inspections. The proposal had been endorsed by the county Board of Health but was rejected by Allegheny County Council in early 2015 amid an outcry from prominent restaurant owners. The department had hoped that the prospect of having to display a poor grade would better discourage problems.
The health department’s enforcement effort has netted both high-end and more casual establishments.
Take the upscale Habitat restaurant at the Fairmont Pittsburgh hotel, Downtown. When a health inspector visited the eatery early last year, she cited it for a host of unsafe practices.
One worker was caught plating undercooked chicken, according to the inspection report. Numerous foods in the cooler were being held at unsafe temperatures. Employees weren’t using thermometers to ensure that meats were properly cooked.
In all, the restaurant racked up nearly two dozen health code violations. With the majority of the problems considered serious, a yellow “Consumer Alert” sticker was slapped on the door warning diners that conditions in the kitchen put them at risk for getting sick. Two days later, the alert was removed after the problems were resolved.
Several weeks later at the New China Inn on Centre Avenue in Oakland, an alert went up after an inspector found the counter-service restaurant infested with mice.
“Fresh and old” droppings littered the facility, according to the inspection report, including under the wok stations, fryers and sink in the kitchen; in the restrooms; on shelves under the front counter; and on racks holding containers and utensils. The alert was removed five days later when conditions improved.
How the system works
The department issues a consumer alert when problems could lead to someone getting sick. The size of the facility and the magnitude of the violations also factor in, according to food safety program manager Donna Scharding.
For example, finding one lukewarm batch of soup would not trigger an alert, but finding multiple items at unsafe temperatures could, especially if the restaurant had a history of similar violations, she said.
When a consumer alert goes up, a restaurant has 10 days to fix the problems, she said. If violations are corrected sooner, the facility can request an immediate follow-up inspection. If problems remain, depending on the severity, the business could be fined or ordered closed.
For particularly serious situations that pose an imminent health hazard — such as a lack of water to the facility, a sewage backup or serious health code violations that have remained uncorrected — the department immediately posts a red “Closed” placard. The facility cannot reopen until problems are fixed.
Dr. Hacker emphasized that the county’s food safety regulations have not changed. However, the department’s resolve to enforce the rules has, she said. “We’re doing the things we’re supposed to be doing.”
For example, one reason that closure orders have risen is that the department has been cracking down on restaurants with expired permits. Permits are issued annually. Fees range from $44 to nearly $2,000, depending on the size of the facility.
To support the overall effort, the food program expanded its team from 17 to 19 inspectors and added a couple of managers to approve alerts and closures. The unit is responsible for inspecting some 8,400 food facilities in Allegheny County.
Fair or unfair?
John Graf, CEO of the Priory Hospitality Group on the North Side and a prominent member of the local restaurant scene, said he had “heard some chatter” recently that “inspectors were being a lot more thorough with inspections.”
“We think restaurants need to be clean and operators need to follow guidelines,” said Mr. Graf, immediate past chairman of the Pennsylvania Restaurant and Lodging Association. “If they are not doing that, and there is a penalty to be paid, we are fully on board with the health department and its efforts.”
One potential concern, he said, is the subjectivity of some food safety guidelines.
“For instance, you can’t have deep knife cuts in a cutting board, but there is no standard for what is deep,” he said.
“It’s our hope the department, when looking at subjective issues, will work with the operator to make sure something is taken care of [over time]. If it’s not subjective, say like food temperatures, someone needs to get right on that.”
So far, Mr. Graf said, “We really haven’t heard any complaints of unfairness.”
But some businesses in the department’s cross hairs have a different view.
After a consumer alert was posted at the Las Palmas grocery store and taco stand in Oakland in January, management posted a sign on the front door accusing the health department of racism.
It contended the alert was an attempt to give the Atwood Street store a “bad reputation” or put it out of business, “only because the owners of this shop happen to be Hispanics.”
The health department “enforces without regard to race, gender, nationality, etc.,” spokeswoman Melissa Wade said in an email then.
Las Palmas manager Yanelis Tome said last week that the owners were frustrated because they felt the business was being unfairly targeted.
The facility had been ordered to close on Nov. 1 because of the “extensive presence of rats, roaches, flies and fruit flies,” in addition to malfunctioning refrigeration, holding food at unsafe temperatures and product on the shelves in unsound condition, including chewed open packages of pasta, beans, rice and cookies, according to the inspection report. The closure followed a consumer alert in September and two in 2015 for similar violations.
Las Palmas reopened in December after undergoing renovations. The Jan. 10 consumer alert was issued after an inspector recorded 14 violations, including holding multiple foods at unsafe temperatures, poor sanitization and an employee handling raw meat and cooked tacos with the same pair of gloves, according to the report. The alert was removed Jan. 24.
“We don’t get a break,” Ms. Tome said last week. “If you go to other businesses, they are a mess, and they don’t order them to close.”
On the frontlines
Restaurant owners unhappy with their inspections can appeal by asking to be heard before a health department hearing officer. “We haven’t had any of those,” Dr. Hacker said.
Some unsatisfied businesses have found other creative ways to act out.
In 2014, the owner of Chinatown Inn on Third Avenue, Downtown, was fined $800 by the health department for concealing a consumer alert decal in the front window with two strategically placed potted plants.
More recently, a $500 fine was levied in November against the Pittzarella pizza shop on the South Side for blocking a consumer alert decal with a menu on one side and a flyer on the other.
The department issues civil penalties based on the size of the facility, willfulness and other factors, the food safety division’s Ms. Scharding said. The department has been issuing more and larger fines since restructuring its penalty policy in 2015. Last year, civil penalties levied by the food safety unit totaled $21,347, up from $6,770 in 2014.
Last month, Frisch’s restaurant in Caste Village in Whitehall was fined $150 plus court costs after a district judge found it guilty of interfering with an inspection.
Owner Dennis Frisch said last week that he had repeatedly asked an inspector to come back another time, but the inspector refused.
“He was here on Halloween, a very busy day, and he was getting in the way,” Mr. Frisch said. “I wasn’t nice to him in the end. I don’t think he was being reasonable.”
Inspection reports for food facilities in Allegheny County are available online at www.achd.net. For a list of consumer alerts and closures, visit http://www.achd.net/food/consumeralerts.html#Alerts. Fines levied against restaurants are not posted online, but a spokeswoman said last week the health department would begin posting them if the county’s legal department approves.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.