Pittsburgh-based insurer Highmark has begun the new year by implementing an incentive payment program for primary care physicians that could significantly change the size of performance bonuses paid, as it encourages doctors to take a larger role in managing their patients’ health.

The latest milepost in a growing health insurance trend linking quality and cost, Highmark’s program features a larger pool of bonus money, tighter qualifying criteria and a nod to the traditional monthly per-patient capitation payment model.

Not everyone has bought into the concept yet. The head of a leading family physicians group in Pennsylvania says doctors may be waiting to see how the program works before deciding if Highmark’s ambitious project will help them provide better care — or simply be another bureaucratic headache.

But Highmark officials say they’re eager to step up their spending on bonuses that they believe will make a difference.

Advertise with us

The “True Performance” program replaces a roster of seven incentive plans across the insurer’s array of commercial and government plans that Highmark medical director Amy Fahrenkopf says made it difficult to compare how well different physicians did at providing quality care while holding down costs.

Now, with a single program that allows apples-to-apples comparisons, she said, “We think we will be able to give much better advice to our members as to which doctors are truly good.”

The voluntary program covers practices in Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Delaware.

Highmark officials estimate that eligible physicians care for about 75 percent of its members, amounting to millions of Highmark members in the three states.

Primary care physicians who see fewer than 250 Highmark members are not eligible because they would not generate enough data to accurately measure their performance.

Advertise with us

UPMC primary care physicians also will be excluded, said Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger, explaining that the program requires coordination and “intense collaboration” that has not been present since the two Pittsburgh health giants went their separate ways.

UPMC physicians continue to be eligible for Highmark’s current Quality Blue incentive program, Mr. Billger said, as required by five-year consent decrees signed by both parties in 2014.

The set-up was criticized by UPMC spokesman Paul Wood, who said the move “is simply a referral mechanism to shift volume” to Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network.

“Highmark is behaving as if the July 1, 2019, expiration of the consent decrees has already occurred. UPMC looks forward to the competition as they expire because it will serve the community well.”

Mr. Wood added that UPMC has had its own physician incentive plans in place for more than five years that “are based on a balance between quality and cost, with quality as the main component of the incentive.”

Advertise with us

Highmark’s new incentive program — 18 months in the works — puts equal weight on quality and cost/​utilization measures, with bonuses added to the customary fee paid for the office visit.

In addition, primary care physicians will receive a monthly per patient “care coordination” payment, regardless of whether they see the patient, which Highmark hopes the doctor will use to help manage patients’ care.

For example, if a practice cares for a large number of patients with diabetes, it might use the money to hire a coordinator who would stay in regular contact with the patients to make sure they were taking their insulin.

Dr. Fahrenkopf said Highmark expects about 40 percent of primary care physicians will earn about the same bonus amount as they have in recent years under the new program, while 30 percent will earn more up to a $2.5 million maximum and 30 percent will earn less.

“In some ways, these programs pay for themselves because the better the provider does with this program, the better Highmark does and the better the patient does,” she said.

Advertise with us

Dr. Fahrenkopf said similar programs have been used in other parts of the U.S. as the American health care system moves away from a payment model that rewards the volume of care to one that puts more emphasis on getting good value for dollars spent.

Still, the head of a leading state association of family physicians said the organization would like to know more about the new Highmark payment model.

“The issue is, how does it relate to the patient? How is the patient experience going to improve?” asked family physician Rob Rodak, president of the Harrisburg-based Pennsylvania Academy of Family Physicians. “If it only improves on the insurance side of it, it’s not helpful.”

Brent Ennis, the academy’s executive vice president, also said there are other steps insurers could take to help primary care physicians be more efficient, such as streamlining the pre-authorization process on prescriptions and expediting the physician credentialing process.

Dr. Fahrenkopf said, “The cost component is what makes the primary care physicians a lot more nervous. They worry they will be evaluated without the right information.”

Advertise with us

But she believes that the new model “aligns the incentives of both Highmark and the physician” to provide quality care in the most cost-effective manner, she said. “We all have the same goal.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.