UPMC is suing a Cleveland financial and business services firm in federal court, alleging that an actuary for CBIZ Inc. understated the pension liability at Altoona Regional Health System by about $132.5 million.
The suit, filed in the Johnstown office of U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, seeks $142 million plus punitive damages.
Pittsburgh health system UPMC acquired the Altoona health system, now called UPMC Altoona, in July 2013, with a commitment to invest $250 million over 10 years to enhance Altoona’s facilities and services while assuming responsibility for its outstanding debt and pension obligations. At the time, Altoona had 6,000 employees.
Before the deal closed, UPMC alleges that an understatement of pension expense meant Altoona’s profitability in the fiscal year ending June 30, 2012, was overstated “by at least $18 million.”
Had the Pittsburgh health system known the true state of Altoona’s pension obligations, the suit states, “UPMC likely would not have acquired Altoona, or in the very least, would have negotiated and structured a different deal for Altoona.”
Mike Gleespan, general counsel for CBIZ, said in a statement Thursday that it disputes the allegations. “We have defenses that will be presented at the appropriate times, and we plan to vigorously contest the litigation. We can’t comment on the allegations in the complaint or on facts of the matter because we don’t want to prejudice the proceedings against UPMC and UPMC Altoona.”
The CBIZ website says the company has more than 100 offices throughout the U.S., providing various financial and business services.
The suit also names a retired CBIZ actuary, Jon S. Ketzner, who UPMC says provided actuarial valuation services for the Altoona plan. Mr. Ketzner, now based in Maryland, could not be reached Thursday afternoon. An Associated Press report said Mr. Ketzner had referred the news service to CBIZ for any comment.
UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said Thursday that, despite the suit’s allegations, the Pittsburgh health system has fully funded Altoona’s pension plan “because UPMC takes seriously its commitment to Altoona as well as its responsibility to fully fund all of its pension plans.”
UPMC is also continuing to invest in Altoona’s infrastructure, including the addition of new clinical programs, he said.
The purpose of the lawsuit, he added, “is to recover the damages and any penalties incurred by UPMC Altoona or UPMC itself as a result of CBIZ’s actuarial errors.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.