Highmark scored near the bottom — below Spirit Airlines and Motel 6 — in a recent customer satisfaction survey by a Massachusetts-based marketing research firm that compared consumers’ experiences with a range of different businesses.
Highmark was not alone among health plans scoring poorly: Temkin Group’s sixth annual survey, conducted in January and based on responses from 10,000 consumers, shows Highmark had the lowest rating among local insurers at 37 percent, followed by Coventry (49 percent), Cigna and United Healthcare (both 50 percent) and Aetna (51 percent).
UPMC Health Plan was not included in the list, indicating that fewer than 100 respondents mentioned it. The complete list can be viewed online at temkinratings.com.

PG graphic: Consumer rankings
(Click image for larger version)
“I think health plans in general have a tough time because often times the health plans have to say ‘no,’” Bruce Temkin, managing partner for the Temkin Group marketing research firm based just outside of Boston, said in a phone interview Monday.
But a rating of 50 percent or lower means consumers are reporting more bad experiences than good experiences, he added.
“Somehow they don’t do a good enough job eliminating those bad moments so people can focus on the good moments.”
Mr. Temkin said the survey rates businesses in three areas: success, effort and emotion.
For a health plan member, for example, the rating might be based on averaging scores of whether that person was successful getting an answer to a question about coverage, the ease with which that was accomplished and how the individual generally felt about the experience.
In response to the survey, Highmark spokeswoman Wendy Morphew said that as health care consumerism matures, and consumers get more information to evaluate the cost and quality of their health care, “We expect health plans will move up in overall consumer satisfaction and score higher on these types of lists.
“Certainly Highmark is focused on its members and customers and creating value for them.”
Mr. Temkin allowed that it would be unfair to single out Pittsburgh-based Highmark among health plans because “they all fail” when it comes to providing a satisfying customer experience.
“My guess is that it’s not worth shifting [to another insurer]” based on a somewhat lower score, he said. “I think they’re all problematic and they’re all working on it.”
Supermarkets, meanwhile, had the highest scores for customer experience, led by Publix, an employee-owned chained based in the South, and the Texas-based H-E-B supermarket chain.
Despite obvious differences in how a customer would interact with a health plan versus a supermarket, Mr. Temkin argued the comparisons can be helpful for sectors trying to improve their customers’ experience.
By benchmarking a health plan only against other health plans, he said, “All you’re doing is reinforcing mediocrity, at best.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.