Highmark has 3 million members total in Western Pennsylvania, the Pittsburgh insurer reported Tuesday, and retains a 60 percent market share regionally for its commercial book of business.
Membership in its Affordable Care Act marketplace plans, however, has dropped from over 350,000 in 2015 to 195,000 this year, including 53,000 in Western Pennsylvania. The insurer has been adjusting its plan offerings after losing about $773 million on those plans over the past two years.
On the commercial side, “We see our membership stabilizing” while the overall market will continue to evolve, said Tony Benevento, Highmark’s senior vice president of regional markets, in a telephone media briefing Tuesday.
Even as national insurers have made inroads into the local market and employers offer more options, he said, “Eight of 10 [employees] continue to pick the Highmark brand.” He said the Pittsburgh insurer enjoys an estimated 95 percent retention rate across all markets.
Highmark and Pittsburgh rival UPMC Health Plan have battled for market share since the UPMC-Highmark in-network contract expired last year. On Tuesday a UPMC spokesman took issue with Highmark’s report of 3 million members in the region, saying, “The math simply doesn’t work.”
“All we know for certain about Highmark is that they claim to have 53,000 individual members, plus 183,000 Medicare Advantage members. … Who are the other 2.764 million members they claim to have?” asked UPMC spokesman Paul Wood.
Last month, UPMC Insurance Services president Diane Holder said UPMC Health Plan’s 2.9 million members — about 1 million more members than it had just five years ago — had matched Highmark for market share in this region for commercial and government plans. Said Mr. Wood on Tuesday: “More people in Western Pennsylvania now purchase their health insurance from UPMC Health Plan than from any other insurer.”
Highmark spokeswoman Wendy Morphew said Tuesday that the 3 million Highmark members for the region “includes our commercial business, nationally based business, ACA, Medicaid, Medicare and Medicare Advantage.”
She said she did not have Highmark’s combined commercial and government market share percentage immediately on hand “but with a 95 percent retention there wouldn’t have been much change in overall market share from last year.”
Highmark does anticipate its marketplace plans will see more losses this year.
Alexis Miller, senior vice president of individual and small group markets, said “close to half” of those who enrolled in the marketplace plans were new to Highmark and “were either uninsured or underinsured.”
They also were older and sought medical care more than anticipated, she said, leaving Highmark to pay out more in claims than it took in premium payments.
The ACA members had 57 percent higher inpatient charges compared with commercial members, she said, as well as 49 percent higher charges for chemotherapy and a 43 percent higher rate of congestive heart failure.
“What we need to do is create a sustainable marketplace,” she said.
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.