After probes by two state attorneys general, plus a second-half general economic downturn that saw his company’s stock price halved, GNC Holdings Inc. CEO Mike Archbold understatedly describes 2015 as “a year of some learning.”
“We found a number of things that worked and a number of things that didn’t.”
What he won’t do is point to the allegations, or the economy, or the weather, or anything else, for what he acknowledged were yearly sales that failed to meet expectations. Simply put, his philosophy is, “No matter what happens it’s our fault.”
In its quarterly and full-year financial report Thursday, the Pittsburgh-based health and wellness retailer reported net income dropped 7.6 percent to $49.9 million in the fourth quarter of 2015, and fell 5.7 percent to $246.5 million for the year, although revenue numbers were up slightly.
GNC did show a 1.8 percent increase in fourth quarter revenues at $618.2 million, up from $607.2 million in the fourth quarter of 2014. For all of 2015, revenue hit $2.64 billion compared with $2.61 billion in 2014, a 1 percent increase.
The company’s initial earnings per share outlook for 2016 is expected to be in the range of $3.15 to $3.35.
On Thursday, GNC shares closed at $26.98, up 42 cents but still well below the 2015 high close of $50.93 in early August.

PG graphic
(Click image for larger version)
To retain shareholders, GNC earlier announced a 20 cent-per-share dividend for the first quarter and has launched an aggressive share repurchasing strategy, buying back 12.4 million shares worth $480 million in 2015.
The focus now, Mr. Archbold told analysts, “is on longer term shareholder value. We’re in this for the long haul.”
He noted some initiatives that proved successful last year: an expanded assortment of products, a store-wide buy-one-get-one promotion in December, product innovations, more targeted marketing and a move to make GNC a 50-50 split of company-owned and franchise stores.
While targeted marketing efforts worked, he said, “Our broader brand marketing efforts were not where we want them to be.” He also wants to further simplify pricing and re-establish GNC’s Gold Card as a loyalty card rather than a discount card.
His biggest task, however, may be the one GNC is taking on with competitors, suppliers, pharmaceuticals and raw material manufacturers: improving public perception of the supplement industry, eliminating questions or doubts about the quality, purity or safety of their products.
The New York investigation a year ago questioned whether labels on GNC products accurately listed ingredients and it was quickly dispatched. The second allegation, from the Oregon attorney general’s office, claimed GNC nutritional and dietary supplements included unapproved drugs.
Mr. Archbold called the allegations in both instances “unfounded and meritless,” adding that “these attacks are undermining consumer confidence” and hurting sales.
To that end, he said GNC is leading a coalition of “40-plus companies” undertaking a number of initiatives, including a system of tracking all ingredients “from the seed before its planted to the shelf when it gets to the stores,” independent third-party inspections and facility certifications.
With the recent hiring of Tim Mantel as executive vice president for merchandising to round out GNC leadership, Mr. Archbold said, “We’ve got the team and we’ve got the plan and now we’re going to start executing the plan.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.