The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid is penalizing eight western Pennsylvania hospitals, including UPMC Presbyterian-Shadyside and Allegheny General, citing the facilities’ higher rates of infections and other safety incidents when compared with other centers.
Presbyterian-Shadyside and AGH both scored 7.75 based on a formula used by CMS that will dock hospitals 1 percent of the usual Medicare payments for a year if they scored above 6.75.
The federal agency said the 758 penalized hospitals represent “the worst performing quartile” of the 3,300 U.S. hospitals reviewed, a designation local hospital officials took issue with.
“Because UPMC takes the ‘sickest of the sick,’ we and other academic medical centers in Pennsylvania and nationwide are the ones most often penalized by CMS,” said Tami Minnier, UPMC’s chief quality officer. “As many other experts have noted, the methodology used by CMS is flawed when it comes to adjusting for the severity and complexity of the illnesses we treat.”

(Click image for larger version)
Physician Sam Reynolds, chief quality officer for AHN, said those who develop hospital-acquired conditions represent “a very small percentage” of the patients they see. Meanwhile, they have 17 teams network-wide that meet weekly to discuss ways to reduce, and hopefully prevent, hospital-acquired conditions such as central-line, surgical site and other infections and preventable complications such as deep-vein thrombosis during the hospital stay.
“We are focused on quality every day,” he said, noting they took steps such as optimizing pre-surgical skin cleansing and limiting foot traffic in and out of the operating room during procedures to prevent infections.
“We don’t want to have any of the acquired conditions.”
Among western Pennsylvania hospitals, the highest score, 9.25, was recorded at St. Vincent Hospital in Erie, also part of the Allegheny Health Network. A third AHN hospital, West Penn was scored at 7.0. The four other hospitals were Ellwood City (8), Heritage Valley Beaver (7.5), Kane Community Hospital (7) and ACMH Hospital in Kittanning, Armstrong County (7).
Dr. Reynolds said “we don’t believe the quality is any worse” at St. Vincent and suspects the higher score may be a matter of not recording that a patient already had an infection when they were admitted.
John Luellen, COO and vice president for quality at Heritage Valley Health System, said the Beaver facility numbers were “historic data and our recent performance is much improved,” adding that they have not had a single hospital-acquired condition among Medicare patients the past two months at either Heritage Valley Beaver or Heritage Valley Sewickley.
“’We do not expect to be on the [CMS] list for the next cycle.”
This is the second year of the federal program, established as part of the Affordable Care Act, which is meant to give hospitals a financial incentive to reduce infections and other hospital-acquired conditions. CMS estimates it will see a $364 million savings from the reduced payments through Oct. 30, 2016.
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.