Believe it or not, Andrew Leheny wants to hear from the IRS.

Mr. Leheny and his wife, Rebecca, of Belle Vernon were among 800,000 Americans given incorrect information in February after they had signed up for an Affordable Care Act marketplace health plan.

Identifying the error was simple: Federal officials had sent out 1095-A tax forms that determined how much of a credit enrollees were due on their tax return. The calculation in those forms was based on the second lowest “silver,” or mid-level, health care plan premium for 2015 — instead of that for 2014.

Fixing that mistake has been anything but simple for the Lehenys.

Advertise with us

For one thing, the marketplace folks compounded the mistake by not crediting Ms. Leheny for her first seven months of coverage in 2014, reducing the low-income credits she qualified for.

All totaled, the Lehenys believe they are owed at least $1,750 and they have been trying unsuccessfully since June to get their money, an effort that has involved hours on the phone and morning-long waits in the Monroeville IRS office.

Now Mr. Leheny just wants to hear from someone at the IRS.

“We’ve initiated the contact. Why isn’t anybody getting back to us?” he asked.

A regional IRS spokesperson this week said she cannot comment on individual taxpayers’ cases but she has heard of no other reports of ongoing problems from the Form 1095-A error. “This is not an ‘emerging issue’ that has been raised to my attention,” said Jennifer Jenkins, who handles media inquiries in Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia.

Advertise with us

That’s little solace for Mr. Leheny, although he wants to make one thing clear: “Obamacare is a godsend for our family.”

After health problems forced Ms. Leheny, 63, to leave her $60,000 job as a speech pathologist in late 2013, they were looking at $609 monthly premiums to maintain their health insurance under COBRA, the program that allows workers and their families to keep health benefits for a period in such situations. That meant digging into their modest savings.

“The bottom line was we needed Obamacare,” Mr. Leheny said.

But the Lehenys’ experience in the marketplace does highlight the complexity some families face in finding a plan every year and applying for a subsidy, all while dealing with two different federal agencies. Even aside from the tax credit matter, it has been an up-and-down ride.

Initially, the family was told the monthly premium would be $373 and then $106 and then $39 per month after learning that some benefit funds they receive would not be counted as part of their annual income.

Advertise with us

But the premium for the family’s same Highmark silver plan is now jumping to $543 per month in January, so the Lehenys are shopping for another plan.

“It’s been very, very challenging,” said Mr. Leheny, 64, who receives disability payments for a heart condition. His wife’s medical problems prevent her from working, too, and their 16-year-old son, Noah, has spina bifida and uses a wheelchair. Their combined disability benefits, plus a small amount Mr. Leheny makes as a freelance writer, amount to just over $30,000 annually.

Before their next benefit check arrives, due today, he said the family had $8 cash on hand. “We’re wiped out now. Our savings are gone.”

Some have suggested the family just file an amended tax return, but Mr. Leheny said he’s reluctant to take any steps until he hears back from the IRS. He said he last called the Internal Revenue Service in September and, other than a minor addition error, the IRS adviser told him she didn’t see any problems with their return.

Three months later, he’s still waiting.

Advertise with us

“What I’m really afraid of is that if we don’t resolve this this year, we won’t get our money back and we really need it,” he said. “All I’m asking for is a professional response.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.