Patrick J. Kelly, 64, had a heart attack at his Shaler home on Sept. 14 and by the time he was transported to Allegheny General Hospital and surgeons could operate, he had suffered irreparable brain damage and needed ventilator support to survive.

Typically, the medical protocol would call for a patient in that condition, once stabilized, to be transferred from the acute care hospital to a facility that could provide the sub-acute yet still highly-skilled care they need.

But, as hospital officials say is happening all too frequently, medical protocol took a back seat to health insurance coverage for Mr. Kelly, who is on medical assistance. He remained in the AGH Neuro Intensive Care Unit for seven weeks because no one was willing to take him.

“We hear that all the time. It is a daily or weekly event in a lot of hospitals,” said Denis Lukes, chief financial officer for the Hospital Council of Western Pennsylvania. “It’s not uncommon at all.”

Advertise with us

It’s not always an insurance issue either, said AGH Chief Medical Officer William Goldfarb.

Between advancements in medical technology and people living longer with complex medical conditions, there is a need for transitional care facilities for patients who no longer need acute care but aren’t well enough to go home, he said.

But because there are not enough available beds in those facilities, or due to delays or denials for authorization by insurers, “Some patients unfortunately remain longer than we’d ideally like to see them in the hospital,” said Dr. Goldfarb.

While acknowledging there are significant financial challenges for the hospital in those situations, the main concern is that it’s not good for the patient to remain in the hospital when the acute care setting no longer has anything to offer that patient, he said.

Sometimes there is no alternative.

Advertise with us

AGH may treat a homeless patient who needs a six-week course of antibiotics post-hospitalization to get well, Dr. Goldfarb said. With no home, there’s no home care service to offer that patient.

“So we keep them here in the hospital. That’s just the right thing to do. It’s part of being a member of the community and doing the things you do to support the community.” The bill then gets recorded as charity care.

Mr. Kelly was on medical assistance which, combined with his ventilator support, made it harder to find a post-hospital placement. His sister, Cynthia Winczner of Lawrenceville, said she called local long-term acute care facilities herself and was told they are not accepting Medicaid patients.

“It felt like Pat is not valued,” said Mrs. Winczner. “It’s not that Pat isn’t going to pass because I know that he is. But he should be able to go out of this life with dignity and respect. He should be able to get the care that he needs and he’s not going to get it.”

Calls to LifeCare and Kindred long-term facilities inquiring about their medical assistance policies were not returned, but Mr. Lukes said it’s often the case that a medical assistance plan does not contract with long-term acute hospitals. That means the facilities may receive no payment for the care they provide.

Advertise with us

“When you do not know the duration of the stay, it makes it that much harder to accept patients,” he said. “I’ve seen cases that go on for years.”

Mr. Kelly finally left AGH on Oct. 30 for a facility in Washington County that specializes in rehabilitation services and cares for patients on ventilators.

But Mrs. Winczner said her brother, a graduate of Central Catholic High School and the University of Pittsburgh who worked for UPS for many years, needed more.

“He needed to be in a long-term acute care setting,” she said. “They should not be able to refuse you. They are basically saying, ‘You don’t have money so we’re not taking you.’”

Mrs. Winczner and her husband Bill make the 75-mile round trip to see her brother nearly every day, and Mr. Kelly’s daughter from New York has been in town. Together they tend to some of his personal needs — shaving him and trimming his hair. Mrs. Winczner said they talk to him even though he can no longer respond.

Advertise with us

“He always took care of me so I take care of him, too,” she said of her older brother. “I feel that’s what families should do.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.