Aetna and subsidiary Coventry/HealthAmerica have sent letters to more than 200,000 of their members saying that emergency room physicians at Allegheny Health Network hospitals are not in their network, even though the hospitals are.
Aetna spokesman Walter Cherniak Jr. said the mailing was precipitated after the physicians in September “began aggressively balance billing our members for the difference between their billed charges and what Aetna paid them,” retroactive to April 2014.
“This change in practice is causing significant angst and unnecessary expense for our members,” he said.
“We’re telling them not to pay the bills, but to contact us so that we can attempt to resolve the issues.”
AHN spokesman Dan Laurent said Allegheny Health Network emergency departments are staffed through a joint venture company formed in 2014 and are owned by AHN and Emergency Medicine Physicians of Canton, Ohio.
“The physicians are employed by the joint venture and EMP has been negotiating separately with Aetna over the past several months to establish a contract for those physician services. We are hopeful that an agreement will be reached soon,” Mr. Laurent said.
Kathleen Wellock, vice president of operations at EMP, was not available for comment by the newspaper’s deadline Thursday afternoon.
The seven hospitals involved are Allegheny General on the North Side, West Penn Hospital in Bloomfield, Alle-Kiski Medical Center in Natrona Heights, Canonsburg General Hospital, Forbes Hospital in Monroeville, Jefferson Regional Medical Center in Jefferson Hills and St. Vincent Health Center in Erie.
Mr. Cherniak with Aetna said there were contracts with the emergency room physicians employed by those hospitals for at least 35 years. When out-of-network physicians occasionally treated their members, they were paid the insurer’s non-participating fee “and there were no issues.”
However, he added, “This all changed” after AHN and Emergency Medicine Physicians formed the joint venture to provide all physician emergency care in AHN hospitals, terminating the contract with Aetna.
“We continued to pay the group according to our non-participating fee schedule,” he said. “We also made several efforts to engage the new entity in contract talks to sign a network agreement. We were unsuccessful.”
The insurers’ letters urge members to “always go to the closest emergency room if needed,” while reiterating that the seven AHN hospitals are out of network and may mean its members will face higher out-of-pocket costs. “If you get a bill for services performed by an AHN emergency room physician, please let us know immediately.”
Mr. Laurent noted that all insurance companies are required by law to pay for emergency medical services regardless of which hospital provides the treatment. “We expect Aetna to meet its obligations to cover both hospital and physician fees at fair market rates for emergency care provided in our hospitals.”
In January, Aetna and AHN reached an agreement that provided Aetna subscribers in-network access to Jefferson Hospital. That resolved a dispute in which Allegheny Health moved to terminate the contract after Aetna said its members should be treated at the lower rates stipulated in Jefferson’s HealthAmerica contract.
Aetna purchased Coventry/HealthAmerica in 2012.
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.