One payment dispute between Highmark and UPMC has been settled, while another appears to be headed for arbitration.

Gov. Tom Wolf on Wednesday announced that Pittsburgh insurer Highmark has agreed to pay some 30,000 of UPMC’s outstanding medical claims made since the beginning of the year.

“This is a major win for consumers, and I applaud Highmark for working with Commissioner [Teresa] Miller and the Pennsylvania Insurance Department to resolve this matter,” Mr. Wolf, a Democrat, said in a release. “My focus is protecting consumers caught in the dispute between Highmark and UPMC, and I have urged both companies to do the same.”

The disputed claims, which represent about 3.3 percent of the 900,000 claims filed by Pittsburgh health care provider UPMC with Highmark since Jan. 1, pertained to whether care would be reimbursed at in-network rates or the higher out-of-network rates.

Advertise with us

The in-network contract between UPMC and Highmark expired Jan. 1. However, some Highmark members can still see their UPMC physicians through 2015 under the agreement reached in last summer’s consent decrees.

Highmark has said it was withholding payment on the disputed claims because it didn’t have enough information to determine if the care was in-network or out-of-network.

“This decision to pay the relatively few unpaid claims is a result of our close cooperation” with state officials, Highmark spokesman David W. Carter said. “Working together, we agree that it’s important to put people first so they don’t get caught in the middle when the information necessary to pay claims isn’t provided by UPMC.”

UPMC spokesman Paul Wood, while expressing gratitude to state officials for resolving the dispute, took issue with Highmark’s explanation.

“Highmark always had more than sufficient information from UPMC to properly and promptly pay the claims,” he said.

Advertise with us

With Highmark now paying the claims, the governor’s office said, patients would be spared from being billed for the balance between the in-network and out-of-network rates.

This is the second time in two weeks that the Wolf administration has intervened in the ongoing Highmark-UPMC battle. Last week, administration officials filed a motion in Commonwealth Court on behalf of Highmark’s Medicare Advantage beneficiaries after UPMC threatened to push them out of network in 2016.

UPMC made the threat in response to Highmark refusing to pay what the insurer considers unjustified markups for cancer treatments. UPMC has countered that the higher payment claims are allowed and that Highmark was violating their contract.

That dispute now appears to be headed for arbitration under the terms of last summer’s consent decree.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.