In the middle of 2010, the owners of Costanzo’s restaurant — then a mainstay in Downtown Pittsburgh — faced a choice: pay their electric bill or buy food to serve customers.

Just a few doors down, late bills were piling up at the 1902 Landmark Tavern.

And across Market Square, the Original Oyster House — a restaurant that had outlasted floods, wars and recessions over 100-plus years in business — was nearing closure as sales plummeted.

It was several months into a major overhaul of Pittsburgh’s oldest public square, a process that shut down roads, blocked sidewalks and drove away usual customers over the course of a year. By the project’s end, only the Oyster House remained open.

Advertise with us

Now, more than a decade later, the restaurant is close to surviving yet another transformative chapter in Market Square’s history as a $15 million, yearlong renovation project wraps up next month.

And this time around, Oyster House owner Jen Grippo said, closing was “never a thought.”

“I always had confidence that we were going to be OK,” she said, adding that the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership — the nonprofit behind both Market Square overhauls — has supported businesses in every way possible, from promotions to financial assistance.

“When you’re a leader, you do not panic — you pivot,” Ms. Grippo said, glancing around her family’s 155-year-old restaurant, where timeworn, black-and-white photos line the walls and advertisements for a limited-edition Pittsburgh Brewing Company beer on tap line the windows.

“We lean on each other,” she continued. “And we get creative.”

Advertise with us
Pedestrians pass workers in Market Square on Thursday, March 26. Business owners in Market Square hope the construction's completion will create a windfall this spring and summer. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

‘I’m sure the snow didn’t help’

The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership broke ground on construction in Market Square in April 2025. The renovation builds on the mission of the first revamp: to make the square more walkable — a closer match to the cobblestone piazzas of European cities.

Once complete, the project will limit traffic to one side of the square, ban parking and significantly expand outdoor dining. An open-air pavilion anchors the space, and infrastructure improvements will allow the square to host larger events.

Crews started on the north side of the plaza and moved to the opposite end after six months. Today, the project is about 85% complete, the PDP said. A ribbon-cutting is scheduled for April 22 — just a day before Pittsburgh welcomes this year’s NFL Draft, a three-day affair coming to Downtown and the North Shore.

“Why not just throw the biggest party you’ve ever had on the first day of the space?” PDP President and CEO Jeremy Waldrup joked at the organization’s annual meeting in March. “[That’s] what you exactly do when you’re moving into your new home. We could not have asked for a bigger deadline, could we?”

With under a month to go, crews are making final touches across the square.

Advertise with us
A list of open businesses in Market Square has been posted on fencing around the construction zone for months. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

On Thursday morning, workers standing atop a platform tinkered with the half-moon-shaped glass roof of the new pavilion. Below, a crew in front of Starbucks swapped out old red brick pavers for new ones in shades of gray.

New light poles and tree pits are in place, and upgrades to the square’s electrical and water systems are finished, the PDP said.

Business owners who have watched the construction up close for the better part of a year say they feel confident the project will wrap up on time.

“As construction works, typically, a lot of times you think it’s far away and it kind of comes together in the last minute,” said Jordan Nicholas, owner of Nicholas Coffee & Tea Co, one of Market Square’s oldest businesses. “I’m sure the snow didn’t help.”

Work on the square progressed through one of Pittsburgh’s harshest winters in years. Extreme cold, near-record snowfall, power outages and windstorms swept the region.

Advertise with us

Construction crews were forced to install heated tents and ground-thaw heaters, the PDP said. For a while, snow-shoveling was a daily occurrence.

“They still show up every day and put in the work,” Ms. Grippo said of construction crews.

‘We were on our own’

The Market Square overhaul will become the second finished project of a historic plan to revamp Downtown.

Gov. Josh Shapiro in late 2024 visited the Cultural District to unveil a $600 million, 10-year Downtown revitalization plan, which includes several office-to-apartment building conversions, investments in cleaner streets and two major public space renovations: Market Square and Arts Landing, an outdoor entertainment space on Eighth Street.

While both projects had been planned for years, the NFL Draft set a clear deadline. Arts Landing will open a few days before Market Square does.

Advertise with us

Local leaders say this revamp could usher in a new chapter for the Golden Triangle — and not for the first time.

Pittsburgh’s Renaissance I, which began after World War II, and Renaissance II, in the 1970s, reshaped Downtown and its skyline. This time, the plan is designed to help a corridor that has struggled to rebound after offices shuttered and businesses went under during the pandemic.

History is indeed repeating itself — particularly in Market Square.

In 2010, the PDP kicked off a $5 million facelift that coincided with major roadwork on Market Street and Forbes Avenue, on the heels of the Great Recession.

“When you’re a leader, you do not panic — you pivot,” Original Oyster House owner Jen Grippo said, glancing around her family’s 155-year-old restaurant in Market Square. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The lengthy construction process forced at least two businesses to close — and nearly killed several others. Ms. Grippo, then a college student watching her parents run the Oyster House, remembers it as a “very stressful time.”

Advertise with us

“We were on our own,” she said.

That’s why she and others were wary of another major overhaul — especially when news of the project came with little warning for business owners.

But more than 10 months before construction started, the PDP began holding stakeholder meetings and about 26 one-on-one discussions with shop owners about what to expect. Mascaro Construction, leading the project, hosted open office hours for merchants to ask questions.

Market Square business owners said those meetings have continued throughout the construction process. And the PDP sends weekly emails detailing activity in the square.

After hearing her parents describe their 2010 experience, Ms. Grippo said that communication this time has been “incredible” compared to the last time.

Advertise with us

“I’m never blindsided by anything,” Samantha Fowler, general manager of The Yard, said while slicing lemons behind the bar of the restaurant’s Market Square location on a recent weekday afternoon.

Mascaro Construction employees have become regulars at Nicholas Coffee; others were invited to join Oyster House staff at a fish fry in the restaurant last week.

“I’ll be happy when this project is over, but it will be a sad day when I don’t get to see these guys every day,” Ms. Grippo said. “They’re so in the fold — they are very much a part of our family now.”

Owners knew they would ‘take a hit’

During construction, the PDP has provided 55 grants totaling more than $234,000 to Market Square businesses to offset lost revenue.

On social media, the organization has partnered with content creators and held contests to promote the plaza.

Advertise with us

A list of open businesses has been posted on fencing around the construction zone for months. And as work continues, the PDP has hosted new events in the plaza — including a “Construction to Couture”-themed fashion show in September.

“Even if folks aren’t necessarily participating, it’s driving them to the square,” Ms. Grippo said.

But certainly not every day.

“Some people don’t think Market Square is open at all,” Ms. Fowler said as just four people ate lunch in The Yard.

“I’ll be happy when this project is over, but it will be a sad day when I don’t get to see these guys every day. They’re so in the fold — they are very much a part of our family now.”

Original Oyster House owner Jen Grippo

The restaurant saw a notable drop in sales after construction started, she said. To cut costs, Ms. Fowler staffed fewer employees per shift and cut down liquor orders.

Advertise with us

Across the street, Medi’s on Market — a fast-casual Mediterranean spot that usually sees a lunch rush — watched revenue drop 40% in May, a month after construction began. Owner Sasha Machel said she had to reduce the restaurant’s weekday hours, close on the weekends and take on more catering jobs. The restaurant received the maximum grant award possible from the PDP.

Since the start of the project, at least one restaurant in the square has closed: Whiskey B’s, a relative newcomer that opened in 2024. But a new business has already moved in: Cocky’s Coop bar and restaurant, which will open ahead of the NFL Draft, restaurant manager Todd Valek said during a soft opening Thursday.

Whiskey B’s ownership could not be reached for comment.

“No matter what, we all knew we were going to take a hit,” said Ms. Fowler. “A lot of the newer businesses, especially, were scared. ... It hurt, but it didn’t hurt to the point where I had to close my doors.”

The only option Market Square shop owners had, Ms. Fowler said, was to stay positive.

Advertise with us

“You have to take a little bit of the loss in order to reap the benefit in the end,” added Mr. Nicholas.

City Works plans to add 13 tables and new plantings to its patio. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

‘We’ve seen the struggle’

After the last Market Square renovation, more than 20,000 square feet of retail space was leased throughout the plaza, the Post-Gazette reported at the time.

Newcomers included local retailers along with regional and national chains, such as DiBella’s Subs and Chipotle, all bringing new foot traffic.

This time, businesses are again expected to see gains. Available space for outdoor dining will increase by 50% to 100% — or around 10 to 18 feet — outside most restaurants, the PDP said.

City Works plans to add 13 tables and new plantings to its patio. Medi’s on Market will resume normal hours and, once the NFL Draft ends, install more seating and flowers in front of the restaurant.

Advertise with us

“I think the spring and summer are going to boom,” Ms. Machel said. “We’ve got to get ready for it.”

Across the square, preparations are ongoing as businesses count down the days until the ribbon-cutting, and the start of the NFL Draft the following day.

The Original Oyster House will co-host a draft kickoff happy hour on April 22. During the draft, the restaurant will open earlier and close later.

City Works is hosting The Draft Network in a private dining room, where the media company will “broadcast to their network in real time,” a restaurant spokeswoman said. The restaurant is also in talks with SiriusXM about a similar event, she added.

From April 17-26, The Yard will open a pop-up bar two doors down from the restaurant in Market Square. After the event ends, staff is considering expanding outdoor dining.

Advertise with us

“I’m pretty hopeful,” Ms. Fowler, the manager, said. “I think everyone else is, too.”

Pittsburgh Public Safety Director Sheldon Williams said officials and stakeholders discussed how to ensure that kids spending time in the Golden Triangle are doing so “in a healthy and safe way.” (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Still, not all business owners are ready to make lasting plans.

“I want to see how they address safety before we commit to any outdoor seating,” said Mr. Nicholas, owner of Nicholas Coffee. “I don’t want to have to police it myself.”

Last Sunday, three juveniles were arrested after a fight involving about 40 people broke out on Forbes Avenue and Market Street. People involved in the melee and law enforcement officers used pepper spray, police said.

In the aftermath, public safety officials and Downtown stakeholders renewed discussions on how to ensure that kids spending time in the Golden Triangle are doing so “in a healthy and safe way,” Public Safety Director Sheldon Williams said during a press conference.

Advertise with us

“At the end of the day, we all want everyone to come down to Market Square,” Ms. Grippo said. “But we just want to ensure everyone’s safety.”

Downtown businesses have long called for more security cameras in the square, Ms. Grippo added. Over the past year, Original Oyster House took part in a pilot program to connect its security cameras to city feeds, allowing police to better monitor Market Square. Now, that program could be expanded across the square, she added.

“Outside of making sure that we preserve an institution and the same traditions, safety for my staff and customers will always be at the top of my priority list,” Ms. Grippo said.

A “long-term plan” for the plaza is crucial, she said — and it must extend far beyond the NFL Draft.

“We want to make sure these businesses that are here remain,” she said. “My family, obviously, we’ve seen the struggle.

“We need all of our partners to have a seat at the table.”