For some, the nearly $600 million plan to rescue Downtown Pittsburgh comes with a sobering reality — it may not be enough.

And that’s not because the initiative itself is flawed in any way. It simply reflects the magnitude of the woes facing the Downtown office market in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The centerpiece of the plan, announced last month by Gov. Josh Shapiro, involves the conversion of six buildings, including the former YWCA on Wood Street, into residential, representing about half a billion dollars in combined capital.

Together those structures total about a million square feet.

Advertise with us

The problem? The amount of office space sitting empty Downtown far exceeds that — tallying nearly 4.2 million square feet by one count.

Some real estate insiders say it could be far higher when taking into account space that is technically being leased but in reality is not being used.

Removing a million square feet of that through the proposed conversions will help, local real estate experts say, but it won’t solve the problem.

“From an office market standpoint, it doesn’t move the needle at all. It gets people Downtown. Hopefully, that will keep companies here and get others to come Downtown,” said Gerard McLaughlin, executive managing director of the Newmark real estate firm.

“I think what the governor is doing is a big plus. But there’s a lot more that needs to be done.”

Advertise with us

‘We need to start somewhere’

The estimates on vacant real estate space don’t even count buildings like BNY Mellon Center, the 1.6-million-square-foot skyscraper that could be empty in 2028 after the BNY master lease expires.

Nor does it contemplate buildings, like BNY Mellon and some others, that can’t be easily converted into apartments or condominiums.

“We have these massive white elephants in town that haven’t been addressed. I don’t think anyone realizes the gravity of the situation,” said Izzy Rudolph, president and CEO of McKnight Realty Partners, which owns a handful of buildings Downtown.

The revitalization plan will take nearly 600,000 square feet of office space off the market in the conversion of the 44-story Gulf Tower, which will be turned into apartments and a luxury hotel. But the other buildings targeted range in size from 36,271 square feet to 163,616.

Many see the proposed rescue plan, particularly as it relates to the office market, as simply a start.

Advertise with us

The Allegheny Conference on Community Development — which was instrumental in crafting the initiative — acknowledged as much.

It stated that the “unfortunate reality” is that the Pittsburgh region is lagging economically behind other benchmark cities and the nation as a whole in the post-pandemic era.

“We have much work to do, and we see the Downtown conversion projects as a catalyst that will drive additional investment. We need to start somewhere, and Downtown is one of our shining gems seen around the world,” conference spokeswoman Hollie Geitner said in a statement.

“Making it a livable community is the beginning of what we believe is to come and we're proud of all of the public and private partners who came together in this monumental effort.”

A recent study done by the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm shows that Pittsburgh also trails many other cities in terms of taking office space out of circulation.

Advertise with us

It found that Pittsburgh peer cities such as Cincinnati, Cleveland, Detroit, Milwaukee and St. Louis have removed a combined 14.4 million square feet of office space — or 5.4% of the total inventory — from the market since 2020.

In addition, big cities like New York, Washington, D.C., and Chicago have done away with 43.6 million square feet, or about 4% of total inventory, after being what JLL called “early adopters” of office-to-residential incentive programs.

Pittsburgh, meanwhile, has eliminated just 1% to 2% of its total inventory, according to the study.

“Conversion activity has been most intense in markets with strong incentive programs, cities with a large share of pre-war office buildings, and major life science hubs that saw a wave of office-to-lab conversions during the early stages of the pandemic,” it stated.

‘It’s going to have an impact’

In Pittsburgh, Jones Lang LaSalle has been calling for a reimagining of Downtown, one with fewer office buildings, more residential, and livelier retail.

Advertise with us

At the same time, Dan Adamski, executive managing director in JLL’s Pittsburgh office, said the $600 million revitalization plan, in and of itself, was “not intended to be the solution to all Downtown’s woes.”

“However, the hope is that it will be a catalyst for Renaissance III, and spurring even more downstream development as confidence in Downtown returns,” he said.

He added that there has been a consistent demand for housing in the Golden Triangle. That, coupled with central business district housing being less expensive on a square footage basis than that in adjacent areas like the Strip District, “signals that office-to-residential conversion projects are poised for continued success.”

But others aren’t sure whether Downtown can cut or convert its way out of its troubles.

Mr. McLaughlin, for one, said he believes there has to be a greater emphasis on recruiting companies to fill some of the empty office space.

Advertise with us

“We need to go out and actively attract companies to relocate to Downtown or to relocate to Pittsburgh, for that matter,” he said.

While Mr. McLaughlin described the revitalization plan as a positive, he said it doesn’t go far enough, particularly in trying to attract businesses to move Downtown.

He suggested, for example, that tax benefits could be offered to companies that relocate. Parking incentives could be another tool. Another idea could be some type of funding to help building owners with tenant improvement packages to help attract tenants.

At the same time, he said he sees value in the revitalization plan crafted by the governor and various local stakeholders.

“It’s going to have an impact. It’s positive and it’s a good thing. The more people you have Downtown, the better Downtown is going to be from a security standpoint, a retail standpoint,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rudolph said he believes the federal government needs to become more involved in helping downtowns overcome office market calamities.

He sees a need for the creation of a loan fund totaling billions of dollars — similar to that offered to automakers in 2008 — that developers and building owners could tap to help offset the cost of conversions.

One problem many building owners face is that they already have too much invested in their properties to justify even more investment for a conversion project. That is particularly true, Mr. Rudolph said, at a time when lenders are being stingy. Whereas banks a decade ago were willing to lend up to 80% of a project’s cost, they are now hesitant to kick in more than 50%, leaving developers struggling to find the rest.

“Right now, that’s an insurmountable gap,” Mr. Rudolph said.

Property assessment reductions add to the woes

Among McKnight Realty Partners holdings Downtown are the Grant Building on Grant Street, the former Gimbels building on Smithfield Street, and the Henry W. Oliver Building, also on Smithfield.

Advertise with us

According to real estate sources, McKnight is considering the potential conversion of the Grant and the office side of the Oliver Building to residential. Mr. Rudolph declined comment. McKnight has already converted part of the Oliver Building to a hotel.

Potentially complicating a Grant Building conversion is that the property is currently tied up in a possible foreclosure action in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.

Jeremy Waldrup, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, said in a statement that the agency is working with its counterparts at the national level “to secure bipartisan legislation to provide tax incentives for converting underutilized office space into housing and are hopeful that Congress will advance (it) in 2025.”

Downtown currently has about 6.9 million square feet of residential space, Mr. Waldrup said. The goal is to increase that to almost 15 million square feet to support more than 15,000 residents while “creating a diverse and resilient neighborhood that supports a wide variety of restaurants and retailers and ensures many of our historic buildings and iconic skyscrapers see investment for years to come,” he added.

“These buildings must include multi-family rental housing, student housing, condominiums, from affordable to market rate.”

Advertise with us

But he stressed the makeover will require an all-hands-on-deck approach.

“Making this a reality will require coordinated public-private partnership, including minimally restrictive, continued investment from the public sector (City, Schools, County, State and Federal) alongside the private investment dollars. With the cost per square foot for a multi-family residential conversion project of a historic, iconic building being significantly higher than ground-up, stick-built structures that is typical in our market, we have to make meaningful investments to ensure this much needed investment occurs,” he said.

Mr. Rudolph argued that if the Downtown office market were to collapse, it would have a ripple effect on the downstream workforce, including retailers, restaurants, office cleaners, and even mass transit.

On the other hand, a revitalized Downtown not only benefits those entities, but local government as a whole in terms of increased property tax revenues. But as the Downtown office market has struggled in the aftermath of the pandemic, the opposite has happened.

Building owners have won half a billion dollars in property assessment reductions in recent years, in part because of high vacancy rates, costing the city, its school district and Allegheny County millions of dollars in refunds and annual property tax revenue.

Advertise with us

One who says he believes that the Downtown office struggles will eventually right themselves is John Valentine, executive director of the Downtown Neighbors Alliance.

“For a savvy investor who can buy low because the value [of an office building] is down, it’s an opportunity,” he said. “I believe it will work itself out. I can’t say whether it will be two years, five years, or seven years. I think there’s a market out there.”

One thing that Mr. Valentine says could help to bring more employees back to offices in the central business district — and by extension help fill some of the vacant office space — is subsidized day care.

The cost of day care and the cost of parking are the “two biggest obstacles” preventing employees from returning to the office that he has found in conversations with workers, he said.

While people may want to get out more, when they weigh that against the cost of day care and parking, “that makes them want to stay home,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. McLaughlin sees another way to help Downtown regain its footing.

“The biggest thing that would help Downtown is if another UPMC came in and took half a million square feet of space. It would be a shot in the arm,” he said.