The Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment has rejected a controversial proposal to tear down an old Victorian house in Shadyside and replace it with a six-unit apartment building.
In a Nov. 15 ruling, the board concluded that Shadyside Enterprises, the owner of the property at 6111 Walnut St., did not meet the requirements of the variance needed to construct the new building.
The decision is a victory for Shadyside residents who live close to the property and officials at the nearby Sacred Heart Elementary School, all of whom raised concerns about the project.
Shadyside Enterprises was required to seek the variance because the property is located in an R1A-H zoning district, which prohibits multi-family residential.
In order to secure the relief, the owner had to show that there were “unique circumstances or conditions” about the property that would result in “an unnecessary hardship;” that there would be no adverse effect on the public welfare; and that the proposed variance was the minimum that “would afford relief with the least modification possible.”

Shadyside Enterprises did not do that, the zoning board found.
Read More
“The applicant failed to present evidence of any unique condition of the subject property or unnecessary hardship that would justify the grant of a use variance,” it wrote. “The applicant also did not demonstrate that the proposed use, for 6 residential units, was the minimum variance that would afford relief.”
In addition, the owner “did not present any evidence to demonstrate that the property could not be used for any of the uses permitted in the R1A-H District,” the board stated.
Sam Brourman, who represented Shadyside Enterprises at the Oct. 3 zoning board hearing, could not be reached for comment.
During the hearing, he told zoning board members that the objective of the new development was to fit in with the neighborhood and update the property so that it “would look better than what we have going on now.”
Lucas Bartosiewicz, the project architect, also argued at the time that there are currently five other properties near the old Victorian house that contain apartments ranging from eight to 16 units.
While many are located in adjacent districts zoned for multiple family, he added that one eight-unit building was situated in the same zoning district as the Victorian property.
“I believe investing money into the context of the neighborhood is a better avenue than building a single-family residential on the site because you’re surrounded by apartment buildings,” he said at the hearing.
Mr. Bartosiewicz could not be reached for comment Monday.
But residents and Sacred Heart school officials argued that the development would increase traffic, create more congestion and have an adverse impact on that section of the neighborhood.
Erin Mascaro, Sacred Heart principal, testified that between traffic, congestion and so many small children being near the site each day, the apartment project “is something that would not be good for our school community.”
She was particularly concerned about safety on Emerson Street, which intersects Walnut at the site of the proposed development. The street is closed off part of the day for recess. It’s also where the entrances and exits to the underground parking planned as part of the apartment development would be located.
Ms. Mascaro could not be reached for comment Tuesday.
Furthermore, Shadyside resident Victoria Verstraenten, who lives on Walnut near the proposed project, testified at the hearing that it was “not fitting in with the style and architecture” of an old Victorian neighborhood.
She said Tuesday she was delighted with the zoning board’s ruling.
Virginia Flaherty, another resident who spoke at the meeting, was pleased as well.
“I received an overwhelmingly good response from Shadyside residents. They are so thrilled that the area that surrounds the school and the churches will remain a beautiful and quiet neighborhood preserving its Victorian charm,” she said.
Shadyside Enterprises has the right to appeal the zoning board decision to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.