Less than five months after a portable restroom was installed on Smithfield Street, the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership is removing the potty and urging people to use the public restrooms in the Smithfield-Liberty parking garage instead.
Jeremy Waldrup, PDP president and CEO, said Thursday the trailer-like restroom — dubbed the Pittsburgh Potty that debuted in September — was never meant to be a permanent solution.
The garage restrooms, located across the street from where the Pittsburgh Potty is situated, will now become just that, with those in need being directed there. The portable potty is to be removed within the next week.
“The intent is to create permanent facilities for folks to use. That was always the plan. These are trailers. They are not made for use indefinitely,” he said.
Mr. Waldrup said the PDP also is searching for a permanent alternative to the Pittsburgh Potty that is located in Gateway Center. Once that is found, that portable restroom will be removed as well.
“The commitment is to long-term access to public restrooms. These were never seen as a long-term fix,” he said.
Read More
The portable potties arrived near the end of summer in a bid to curb public urination and defecation in Downtown, with many business owners complaining about people doing their business in alleys or right out in the open.
At the time, the PDP and other Downtown stakeholders billed the initiative as a six-month experiment, with the goal to provide permanent relief.
The potties were funded through $2 million raised by the Allegheny Conference on Community Development to fight issues like crime, safety, open drug dealing and use, cleanliness and lewd behavior in Downtown.
Like the portable potties, Mr. Waldrup said the public restrooms in the Smithfield-Liberty garage would be open from 7 a.m. to 11 p.m. and staffed at all times by PDP employees with support from the Pittsburgh Parking Authority, which owns and manages the facility.
The men’s and women’s restrooms are located in the lobby of the first floor of the garage on the Smithfield Street side. There will be a permanent sign directing people to the garage and the bathrooms.
David Onorato, parking authority executive director, said he’s willing to keep the restrooms open to the public long term as long as the initiative doesn’t affect garage operations or negatively impact customers. He noted that he has received assurances from the PDP that that wouldn’t happen.
“So we’re on board with it,” he said.
The authority is not being paid for the use of the restrooms.
While there were some concerns within the Downtown community about a portable potty being located on Smithfield, people were for the most part pleased with the result once it was there, Mr. Waldrup said.
“Staffing is the key. You have to have these things attended,” he said.
Jon Colburn, parish administrator for the Smithfield United Church of Christ, said it was “great news” that a permanent solution had been found. The removal of the portable restroom was “happening sooner than we thought.”
“The entire issue is that there are no public restrooms in Downtown Pittsburgh. If the parking authority is good with it, as it seems to be, and the Downtown partnership is to maintain it, I think [the garage restroom] is a good idea,” he said.
The church, he added, had no issue with the Pittsburgh Potty being outside its front door. It was neither intrusive nor problematic in the time it was there, he said.
“How could we have an issue? It’s a human dignity issue. Restrooms need to be provided. When Jeremy and city officials went through possible locations, one of the best ones was right outside our front door,” he said. “If it wasn’t there, people would have continued to use Strawberry Way as a public restroom.”
The 96-year-old church building, which dates to 1927, is perhaps best known for serving as a cold-weather shelter for homeless people for years. Amid controversy over homelessness in Downtown, the county shut down the shelter in June with no plans to reopen it.
Jack Cohen, owner of S.W. Randall Toyes and Giftes across from the garage, said having a public restroom there is “a little better, I guess,” than keeping the portable potty on the sidewalk near him.
“At least this way you won’t see them going to the bathroom,” he said. “It’s better than them pooping on the sidewalk.”
Having the portable potty near his store hasn’t affected business, he added. The bigger issue, he maintained, is the continued presence of homeless people around his store.
Carl “Guy” Herrmann, owner of Carl Herrmann Furs next to S.W. Randall, said he had pitched the idea to the PDP to use one of the vacant retail spaces under nearby Mellon Square for a public restroom. He wondered how many people would use the restrooms in the garage.
“To put it in a public parking lot, I don’t know,” he said. “I don’t know one person Downtown who used [the portable one].”
While the portable potty in Gateway Center will stay open for now, Mr. Waldrup said the PDP continues to search for permanent alternatives.
He said the trailer-like portable restrooms are not ideal in that they have to be serviced multiple times a week and are not connected to a sewer line.
“Our intent is to close these as soon as we can, as soon as we have a viable option,” he said.
Mr. Onorato said the parking authority has had preliminary conversations with the PDP about possibly using the restrooms in the lobby of the garage at Fort Duquesne Boulevard and Sixth Street for the general public.
“We haven’t come that far along in the discussions. We were mostly working on the Smithfield one,” he said.
In a 2022 study, Point Park University recommended opening up public restrooms in Downtown parking garages.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.