A prominent Penn Avenue property owned by Chatham University near Bakery Square could soon be changing hands.

And the would-be buyer is another big school with real estate holdings in the same block.

Carnegie Mellon University is in talks with Chatham about buying the 250,000-square-foot building known as Chatham Eastside at the corner of Penn and Fifth avenues in Larimer, according to real estate sources.

Chatham put the 7.5-acre property, which includes a 300-space parking lot behind the building, up for sale last summer.

Advertise with us

It did so about the same time that it offered nearly half the building — about 123,000 square feet in all — for lease in the booming corridor just steps from Bakery Square and across the street from Mellon Park. Space is available on the first, second and third floors. Chatham still uses more than 80,000 square feet of the building, which houses its School of Health Sciences, Center for Women’s Entrepreneurship, Women’s Business Center, and other programs.

Spokespeople for CMU and Chatham didn’t return emails seeking comment Thursday. David Koch, a Newmark executive managing director who is marketing the property, declined comment.

A purchase would make sense for CMU. The university currently owns two properties adjacent to Chatham Eastside on the same side of the block. One houses CMU’s Cyert Center for Early Education.

Carnegie Mellon acquired the building at 6543 Penn for $2.35 million just three years ago, according to Allegheny County real estate records. It secured the property at 6555 Penn next to Chatham Eastside in 1993 for $1.35 million.

Chatham bought the Chatham Eastside property in 2008, county records show. According to the marketing brochure, about 80,714 square feet on the first floor offers ceiling heights greater than 18 feet. The building also features multiple loading docks on the lower level.

Advertise with us

The property is located about a mile from Chatham’s Shadyside campus. The university began marketing it after Management Science Associates gave up 123,000 square feet last year to move to Bakery Square.

At the same time, the property offers a buyer easy access to Bakery Square amenities, including Trader Joe’s and the East Liberty Target.

Walnut Capital, the Bakery Square developer, is also seeking to rezone and redevelop the adjacent Eastside Village shopping center for mixed uses that could include apartments and offices.

The potential sale of Chatham Eastside comes at a time when the university is wrestling with a deficit totaling about $6 million.

That’s down from $8 million to $12 million in July. The shortfall was cut to $6 million through a campus-wide reorganization that included the layoff of 20 staff members, a restructuring of the leadership team and consolidating four departments into one.

Advertise with us

Under its new president, Rhonda Phillips, Chatham has initiated a two-year plan designed to enhance the campus experience, further academic excellence and increase fiscal efficiencies.

School officials have attributed the university’s budget problems to issues such as rising costs, an aging financial system and shifting enrollment trends.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com