An Oakland property owner has joined a federal lawsuit challenging a city zoning ordinance designed to increase the stock of affordable housing, claiming it has forced him to halt plans for a mixed-used residential redevelopment because of the costs involved.
The allegation is contained in an amended complaint filed this month in U.S. District Court by the Builders Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh.
It expands on a lawsuit filed last May by BAMP, in which the nonprofit trade association representing builders and developers charged that the city’s inclusionary zoning ordinance was unconstitutional and a violation of Pennsylvania’s Home Rule and Optional Plan law.
BAMP filed the amended action after an ordinance took effect in March that expanded inclusionary zoning requirements to parts of Oakland, including the UC-E district where Dr. Randy Werrin owns four properties.
The latest complaint also is an attempt to counter claims by the city that the lawsuit should be dismissed because BAMP cannot show that any of its members have actually been affected by the ordinance. Dr. Werrin is a BAMP member.
In an April ruling, U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville denied the city’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit, but warned BAMP that it will face “a far more substantial hurdle of establishing standing at the next stages of the proceedings.”
Read More
“This removes one of the hurdles we had,” BAMP Executive Director Jim Eichenlaub said of the amended complaint.
Under the city ordinance, which started in Lawrenceville in 2019 and expanded to Bloomfield and Polish Hill last year before adding Oakland, at least 10% of the housing in new developments or substantial improvements involving 20 units or more must be designated for low-income residents for at least 35 years.
In the amended complaint, BAMP charged that Dr. Werrin could be facing a more stringent requirement for 100% affordable housing in the UC-E zoning district if he builds a mixed-use structure where more than 50% of the gross floor area is residential.
The requirements “severely negatively limit Werrin’s property rights, as well as the value and utility of the Werrin properties,” the lawsuit claimed.
“Because of the negative impact on the value of the Werrin Properties and the increased cost to develop them due to Ordinance 2022-0592, Dr. Werrin has been unable to reach an agreement to sell and/or develop the Werrin Properties with any developer,” it stated.
According to the complaint, Dr. Werrin bought the properties before the Oakland ordinance was enacted.
“This reckless ordinance forces property owners to act as an adjunct governmental housing authority and now my project and others are on halt. The real result is less housing in Pittsburgh and less affordable housing,” he said in a statement in BAMP’s press release announcing the amended complaint.
A spokeswoman for Mayor Ed Gainey, who has made affordable housing a priority for his administration, declined comment, citing the ongoing labor dispute involving the Post-Gazette.
BAMP has maintained that the city was improperly seeking to shift funding for affordable housing to “a select population, namely residential real estate developers” and that the ordinance amounts to an unconstitutional taking of land.
Mr. Eichenlaub has argued that inclusionary zoning is effectively a tax on housing because it forces developers — or those renting 90% of the units — to subsidize the cost of the affordable ones. However, the city has countered that enacting inclusionary housing overlay zoning districts fell “well within” its zoning authority and that neither the constitution nor state law restricts its ability to do so.
In the past, it has estimated a shortage of 8,200 housing units affordable to households at or below 30% of the area median income.
The city’s efforts to defend inclusionary zoning have won the support of neighborhood groups like Lawrenceville United, the Bloomfield Development Corporation, the Polish Hill Civic Association, the Hill District Consensus Group, and the Fair Housing Partnership. They have stated that the median home price in Polish Hill has shot up from $70,000 to more than $210,000 between 2015 and 2018. Lawrenceville also has been battered by soaring housing prices.
Kevin Quisenberry, litigation director of the Community Justice Project, has said that Pittsburgh has lost thousands of affordable housing units over the past two decades and that market-driven developments have pushed rents higher throughout the city, making it harder for lower-income residents to find a place to live.
The inclusionary zoning ordinance is “an important tool” in combating such trends, he has stated.
In its release, BAMP said it is willing to work with the city and others to come up with a strategy that balances “diverse housing needs without infringing on the rights of property owners or stalling development.”
“BAMP remains committed to working with the city’s officials, the community, and all stakeholders to help craft housing policies that are fair, legal, and beneficial to all Pittsburgh residents,” it stated.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.