A Greensboro, N.C.-based grocery chain whose motto is to “make everyday eating extraordinary” is ready to bag up the vacant Whole Foods Market space on Centre Avenue in East Liberty.

The Fresh Market, according to local real estate sources, is in the process of finalizing a lease to take over the 32,500-square-foot store at 5880 Centre that triggered a wave of development dating back more than two decades and helped transform East Liberty.

Whole Foods abandoned the space a year ago to move several blocks away to the Liberty East, a nine-story office and retail development at the site of the former Penn Plaza apartment complex.

The natural foods grocery chain did so after a run of nearly 21 years on Centre in a store legendary for its narrow aisles inside and crowded parking outside.

Advertise with us

Herky Pollock, the CBRE executive vice president who has been brokering the former Whole Foods space, declined comment. A spokeswoman for The Fresh Market could not be reached for comment.

The Fresh Market currently has only one location in the region — at 1551 Washington Road in Mt. Lebanon.

Overall, the grocery chain, which got its start in Greensboro in 1982 in a 14,000-square-foot space, now has 159 locations in 22 states, including four on the eastern side of Pennsylvania.

The store boasts of being a “destination for those looking to discover the best including convenient, restaurant-quality meals, hand-picked produce, premium baked goods, fresh-cut flowers, custom-cut meats and carefully curated offerings for holidays and special occasions.”

Stores typically include meat and seafood departments, fresh produce, baked goods and numerous organic options.

Advertise with us

Last year, Cencosud, a South American retail conglomerate, reached an agreement to acquire a 67% stake in The Fresh Market, with the supermarket founders Ray and Beverly Berry and company management retaining a minority equity interest.

As part of the transaction, the conglomerate agreed to invest $676 million to purchase a combination of primary and secondary equity in the chain, including $265 million in cash.

The deal represented Cencosud’s first investment in the United States.

At the time, Jason Potter, CEO of The Fresh Market, said the partnership would help to expand the chain’s footprint “in our core Southeast market and beyond.”

While The Fresh Market doesn’t compare in size with Walmart or other big grocery chains, it has proven to be popular with some shoppers, voted as “Best Supermarket in America” by USA Today’s 10 Best Readers’ Choice Awards in 2022 and 2021 and “America’s Best Customer Service 2021” by Newsweek and Statista.

Advertise with us

The former Whole Foods site in East Liberty is owned by a partnership run by LaSalle Investment Management.

Efforts to find a new tenant started after Whole Foods made clear last year that it had no plans to try another concept at the site. Its lease expired about the same time it moved to Liberty East.

Before settling on The Fresh Market, the partnership considered other potential reuses, including office, medical-related, and flex space. At one point, it also was considering a possible vertical development for residential or office use.

When Whole Foods opened in October 2002, it helped to launch a renaissance that has transformed much of East Liberty while at the same time sparking questions and concerns about gentrification.

In fact, the Liberty East development that Whole Foods later moved into displaced more than 200 residents from the Penn Plaza apartment building, which was demolished.

Advertise with us

The controversy triggered demands for the creation of more affordable housing in the city amid concerns about displacement and rising housing costs in East Liberty, Lawrenceville and other neighborhoods.

Other nearby projects since the 2002 opening of Whole Foods on Centre have included a Target store; a $156.9 million multistage transit-oriented development that includes 360 luxury apartments and 43,000 square feet of mixed commercial development; and a Giant Eagle Market District and 241 apartments at the site of the former Shady Hill Center shopping complex.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com