The owner of Gulf Tower is battling its former insurer over claims related to the May 2021 fire that shut down the iconic Downtown skyscraper for nearly six months.

In a 34-page lawsuit filed last week, building owner 110 Gulf Associates, an affiliate of Rugby Realty, and Draxxhall Management Company, the tower manager, accused the Zurich American Insurance Company of “a nefarious course of conduct” designed to minimize the money it would have to pay out as a result of the blaze.

They maintained they are owed another $104 million in damages needed to restore the building to its state before the fire. That’s on top of the $48.7 million Zurich has already paid out, according to Jonathan Kamin, the attorney for Rugby and Draxxhall.

Among the lawsuit’s allegations is that because of Zurich’s refusal to pay what it should, Signal USA, a restoration contractor, has filed a $15.4 million mechanic’s lien against Gulf Tower for nonpayment of an invoice. The owners “do not have any other free cash” to pay it, the lawsuit, filed in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, contends.

Advertise with us

However, Zurich has filed its own lawsuit against Rugby and Draxxhall, also a Rugby affiliate, in New Jersey, challenging some of the cost estimates the two provided over fire-related remediation efforts.

The legal battles come at a time when Rugby is trying to transition at least part of the building at 707 Grant St. from office to a hotel and up to 215 apartments as it waits for a permanent electrical system to be installed. The tower’s office occupancy is about 65%.

Originally the headquarters for Gulf Oil, the tower, once Downtown’s tallest building, is perhaps best known for the KDKA-TV weather beacon that sits at its top showing temperature, precipitation, humidity and wind speed in an array of colors.

Battle of hygienists

Rugby and Draxxhall maintained in their lawsuit that Zurich tried to minimize payouts for fire-related losses when it realized that those costs would exceed the $10 million maximum that it had assigned to the account.

Advertise with us

According to the complaint, Rugby had insured all of its properties through Zurich for a total of $450 million.

But the lawsuit alleged that Zurich’s internal underwriting placed the maximum probable loss on the account at $10 million. As a result, it did not purchase any co-insurance, meaning that it would be entirely responsible for all losses.

Once Zurich realized its obligations related to the fire would far exceed $10 million, it “began to engage in a nefarious course of conduct to minimize, to the plaintiffs’ detriment and Zurich’s benefit, all of the expenditures which Zurich would have to make associated with the fire loss,” the complaint stated.

It charged that the insurer tried to do this in several ways, from minimizing areas of the building that needed to be cleaned after the fire to reneging on its obligations to pay for damage to the electrical system.

While Zurich at first had agreed to clean floors one through six of the tower, it refused to authorize the cleaning of soot and other contaminants from the elevators and the spaces above the ceilings “in order to save and/or defer significant financial costs associated with the same.”

Advertise with us

According to the lawsuit, the sampling needed to determine if the areas were to be cleaned was to be done jointly by industrial hygienists hired by Rugby and Zurich.

After the initial sampling found that the areas did, in fact, need to be remediated, Zurich’s industrial hygienist collected its own samples without the knowledge of the other side, the lawsuit claimed.

Those results “miraculously” found that the level of soot and other contaminants were below the standards agreed to by both sides for cleaning, the lawsuit alleged.

But, “concerned about the lack of transparency and the incongruency of these results with the prior testing,” the Rugby and Draxxhall hygienist sampled the same areas and submitted them to a lab other than the one the two sides had been using. It found that 10 of 12 were above the agreed-to standards, the lawsuit claimed.

Later, again concerned that “something nefarious was happening between” Zurich, its hygienist and the original testing lab, the Rugby and Draxxhall hygienist and two others they hired collected samples from the elevator shaft and submitted them to that lab without identifying them as coming from Gulf Tower, according to the lawsuit. All came back above agreed-to levels, it stated.

Advertise with us

Yet despite the “wealth of information” in the various reports, Zurich did not authorize the cleaning of the spaces above the ceiling until six months after they were first determined to be contaminated and is “‘still conducting its investigation’” into whether the elevator shafts need to be cleaned.

Zurich’s “intentional delay” in the cleaning of the ceiling spaces has cost Rugby thousands of dollars in additional testing fees and expenses, and will increase the cost of cleaning the elevators, the lawsuit asserted.

“Moreover, the elevators’ mechanicals have been exposed to [contaminants] for more than two years due to Zurich’s breach of its contractual and fiduciary duties, as well as Zurich’s malevolent desire to make any issue that requires the expenditure of funds as difficult and as protracted as possible,” it stated.

Other conflicts

In addition, Rugby and Draxxhall and Zurich are fighting over the costs of replacing the Gulf Tower electrical system and fire safety work.

Advertise with us

Last September, Rugby and Draxxhall estimated the cost of replacing the electrical system at $38.4 million, while Zurich just two months ago calculated it at $19.5 million, the lawsuit alleged. It also informed Rugby at that time the cost of replacing the system would be limited to $25 million, based on a sublimit in the insurance policy.

But Rugby and Draxxhall maintained that the sublimit doesn’t apply, and that Zurich “delivered a baseless estimate” on the electrical system’s replacement cost to reduce its own financial exposure.

The two sides also are tussling over the cost of the building’s fire safety work. Rugby, in September 2022, estimated that cost at $5.3 million. However, two months ago, Zurich calculated it at $1.8 million after receiving a quote from a contractor.

According to the lawsuit, Zurich did not give the contractor the complete set of fire work plans to get the quote. It also made “material and unauthorized changes” to the plans that included “unilaterally reducing the scope of work that plaintiffs’ licensed professionals declared was necessary to perform.”

“Zurich knew when it presented this information to plaintiffs, and in its filed pleadings, that its quote for the fire safety work was bogus. Yet, in order to reduce its damages, Zurich has continued to promulgate this lie in breach of its contractual and fiduciary duties to plaintiffs,” the lawsuit charged.

Advertise with us

The mention of “pleadings” refers to the lawsuit Zurich filed last month in the Superior Court of New Jersey challenging the claims of Rugby and Draxxhall.

In that litigation, Zurich maintained that Rugby and Draxxhall estimated the cost of upgrading the electrical system at about $80 million. It asserted, though, that those costs are limited to $25 million under the policy’s increased cost of construction coverage.

Likewise, the Zurich lawsuit stated that Rugby and Draxxhall are seeking reimbursement for $12.2 million in costs related to climate control and fire watch after the blaze. But it claims that such expenses are limited to $5 million under the insurance coverage.

The Zurich lawsuit also includes the cost dispute over the fire safety work. The insurance company is asking a judge to settle the conflicts in its favor.

Rugby and Draxxhall, in their lawsuit, are accusing Zurich of breach of contract and bad faith.

Advertise with us

In addition, they are seeking injunctive relief to force Zurich to deliver the fire safety work for $1.8 million, arguing that time is of the essence since it must be done by Dec. 31 to keep the building occupied.

A Zurich spokeswoman declined comment on the Rugby and Draxxhall lawsuit.

Gulf Tower is no longer insured by Zurich.

Rugby reopened the 44-story skyscraper to tenants and visitors on Nov. 1, 2021. At the time, Rugby estimated that it had spent more than $20 million restoring the property.

According to the city’s fire investigation unit, the fire was caused by a failure of the secondary phase of the building’s electrical system.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com