The long ordeal over what figure to use to set taxable value in 2022 Allegheny County property assessment hearings could finally be close to a resolution.
In a decision issued Tuesday, Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court President Judge Renee Cohn Jubelirer ordered the state tax equalization board to recalculate the common level ratio used in those hearings to find a property’s assessment after fair market value has been determined.
She also gave STEB, which typically is responsible for computing the ratio used by counties in Pennsylvania, 30 days to complete the task.
The two-page order could finally bring some much-needed clarity to a situation that has confused and confounded taxpayers for the past year.
In all, there have been three common level ratios in play at one time or another for use in 2022 — 81.1%, 63.53%, and 63.6%.
Since STEB usually has the final say in such matters, the recalculation should settle the matter, at least according to those who have been involved in litigation to lower the ratio.
Read More
“[Tuesday’s] opinion was a defining moment in this process,” said Mike Suley, a former county assessment director and board member who served as a consultant to the property owners who sued to lower the ratio.
But Robert Max Junker, an attorney representing the Pittsburgh Public Schools, isn’t so sure. The district, in a separate case, is challenging before Commonwealth Court a ruling by Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg last year that set the ratio at 63.53%.
“We’ll have to see what the order actually says, what STEB does in response, and what are the next steps in our case,” Mr. Junker said.
The controversy began more than a year ago when John Silvestri, the attorney for the property owners who sued, challenged the 81.1% ratio originally computed by STEB for use in 2022, claiming the number was based on inaccurate county sales data.
In September, Judge Hertzberg ordered 63.53% to be used after the county revised the sales data. Mr. Silvestri’s experts used that data to calculate that ratio.
At the same time, Judge Hertzberg mandated that the revised data be sent to STEB for a formal recalculation, with that figure to be used in hearings.
But that never happened because of the Pittsburgh district’s appeal of the judge’s order. The district claimed that the jurist did not have the authority to set the ratio — that only STEB can do that.
Oddly enough, Judge Jubelirer’s order Tuesday was not a result of the school district’s appeal, but a separate case filed by Mr. Silvestri after the STEB board declined his request to review the county’s sales coding and establish a new common level ratio.
Mr. Silvestri appealed to Commonwealth Court. That led to an agreement with the state attorney general’s office requiring STEB do the recalculation, as outlined in the court order.
The attorney believes the order renders the Pittsburgh Public Schools’ still-pending appeal of Judge Hertzberg’s ruling moot, since one of the district’s main arguments was that only STEB could calculate the common level ratio.
He also noted that Judge Hertzberg had, in fact, ordained the STEB computation as part of his order.
“Now that we have the calculation, the court order is complete. It’s fulfilled. When a court order is [completed], there’s nothing to appeal,” he said.
But Mr. Junket disagreed, saying there are still timing issues involved.
He pointed out that at this point in 2023 there still isn’t a final common level ratio for last year. He said any issues involving the ratio should have been addressed by fall 2021.
“This is sort of a breakdown of the administrative process and indicative of the problems with Pennsylvania’s assessment system, for one, and Allegheny County’s in particular. It should not take two years almost to calculate that number, one that mathematically is not that complex,” he said.
One person hoping that the ratio to be recalculated by STEB will bring closure to the long battle is David Montgomery, the county property assessment board solicitor.
“I think this should end the case. It seems to satisfy what everyone is looking for — a common level ratio based on the information the county has provided to STEB under [Judge Hertzberg’s] order,” he said.
He stressed that it would be good for the board to get a number that it can confidently use to set taxable value.
With thousands of 2022 appeals still to be decided, the only determinations the board has been issuing involve those where there’s no change in value since those cases don’t involve use of the common level ratio.
“We’ve been sort of tied up in knots because we don’t want to issue decisions [involving] a common level ratio that later changes,” he said.
Beyond the 2022 challenges carried over to this year, the assessment board will be handling more than 6,000 appeals from taxpayers who were given a second chance to appeal their 2022 assessments by the county because of Judge Hertzberg’s ruling.
Mr. Silvestri believes the new ratio computed by STEB also should apply at the Common Pleas Court board of viewers level, where taxpayers go if they are unhappy with decisions by the assessment board.
He said property owners have been settling cases at much higher ratios than 63.53% or 63.6% because of the lack of clarity.
Mr. Silvestri expects the number that is recalculated by STEB to be about 63.5%, the same as mandated by Judge Hertzberg last September. He is anticipating a decision from STEB next month.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.