The regional office market is taking it on the chin, vexed by record high vacancy rates, the lowest amount of space under construction in six years and a massive increase in Pittsburgh zoning review fees that could further hamper development.
And some are predicting that it won’t get better anytime soon.
That in essence sums up the findings in the first-quarter office reports released this week by three local real estate firms — Newmark, Jones Lang LaSalle, and CBRE.
Newmark and JLL were particularly frank in their assessments, with the former describing it as a “rocky start to the year.” It offered a glum forecast as to when the market could see improvement.
“With a quarterly net absorption of negative 659,280 square feet and a vacancy rate of 23.4%, it is becoming clear that the market will take a substantial time to rebound,” Newmark stated.
Adding to the woes is that the 690,000 square feet of office space currently under construction is the lowest since 2017.
Newmark noted that the market is beset by challenges, including high interest rates and cost cutting and layoffs, particularly in the tech sector, because of concerns over a longer economic downturn.
And it warned that the huge increase in zoning review fees — estimated at 2,000% — implemented by the city in January isn’t helping matters.
“A massive increase in Pittsburgh permitting and zoning fees has also become a recent setback and an incremental challenge for developers and construction projects,” the Newmark report stated.
A number of local developers have expressed outrage over the fee increase for commercial zoning reviews. Shadyside-based Walnut Capital has urged the city to suspend enforcement, arguing that the increase is illegal and amounts to an “unauthorized tax.”
Jonathan Kamin, Walnut Capital’s attorney, has stated that under state law, such fees must be directly related to the costs incurred by the municipality in issuing a permit or in performing work associated with the application.
He has said that the $255,000 fee Walnut Capital would be charged for an apartment and hotel project it wants to do in Oakland would exceed the annual salaries of the people doing the zoning review. Last year, the same review would have cost $14,050.
NAIOP Pittsburgh is working with a group of developers to arrange a meeting with Mayor Ed Gainey to discuss the issue and possibly negotiate a lower fee that still would generate enough money to cover the city’s costs while giving developers relief.
For commercial developments, the zoning review fee is $3 per $1,000 of project cost — “a staggering 2,000% increase from last year,” Newmark stated.
Of the 690,000 square feet of office space now under construction, one project — the 26-story First National Bank Financial Center at the former Civic Arena site in the lower Hill District — accounts for most of it with nearly 470,000 square feet.
Burns Scalo Real Estate also is building a 180,000-square-foot office building as part of its Diamond Ridge development in Moon.
The paltry construction numbers are but one problem facing the market.
In its report, JLL stated that the overall market first-quarter vacancy rate, at 21.8% (slightly lower than Newmark’s 23.4% estimate) reached its highest point in 25 years, as companies look to shrink their office footprint with so many employees working from home at least part of the week.
In the first quarter of 2020, the vacancy rate was just 15.1%, it pointed out.
“Large corporate users had slowly been giving back space since before the pandemic, but downsizings have intensified in recent quarters as large expirations are coming closer to term, coupled with reduced space needs as a result of hybrid work,” the report stated.
JLL was not optimistic about a turnaround.
“Vacancy will increase in the coming quarters as evidenced by upcoming large lease expirations and announced downsizings that are looming on the horizon,” the report explained.
Despite the vacancies, it pointed out that rents have remained fairly stable, with landlords offering increased concessions, including bigger tenant allowances, to stave off decreases.
Adding to the misery is that the amount of vacant subleased space available hit nearly 1.5 million square feet in the first quarter, according to JLL. That number was affected by Highmark’s decision to sublease five floors, or up to 145,000 square feet of space, at its Fifth Avenue Place headquarters.
“It is clear the hybrid-work model is having an impact on the market, and many companies are opting to redesign their office space. This is frequently resulting in less square footage while creating more collaborative spaces,” the Newmark report stated.
In Downtown, Newmark stated that ongoing concerns about safety continue to be an issue. It reported that one law firm is moving to the South Side mainly because of such worries. Other firms are threatening to leave or reduce their presence. Wiener World, for instance, may close or relocate at the end of June because of drug-dealing, overdoses and lewd acts near its longtime Smithfield Street restaurant.
In an effort to address the issues, Mr. Gainey has taken a number of steps, the most visible being an increased police presence in Downtown.
The Golden Triangle vacancy rate jumped to 22.8% in the first quarter, up 1.4% from the last quarter, according to Newmark.
There was an additional 286,996 square feet of space placed on the market than was leased, the highest amount in the region, the report stated.
Not all the news was bad.
The 277,000 square feet of leasing activity in the central business district in the first quarter was the highest volume since before the pandemic, CBRE reported.
Among the gains in the Downtown fringe market, People’s Gas filled an entire fifth floor sublease in its North Shore headquarters.
CBRE also reported that Hatch, a Canadian-based engineering firm whose Pittsburgh office is considered its unofficial U.S. headquarters, is moving from Gateway View Plaza on the South Side to a nearly 35,000-square-foot sublease on the North Shore. That would amount to a reduction from the little more than 50,000 square feet it currently has.
In the first quarter, the Parkway West submarket also experienced difficulties, with the vacancy rate jumping 2% to 27.2%, the highest in the region, Newmark stated.
Even the booming Oakland/East End corridor wasn’t immune to the issues caused by the pandemic — and, more recently, by higher interest rates and construction costs.
Its vacancy rate topped 25% in the first quarter, driven in part by the decision by Philips to vacate two more floors of space at its Bakery Square headquarters.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.