Another battle is brewing over development in Oakland.
Walnut Capital is suing over a dozen properties it agreed to buy on Halket Street, claiming that the owners have refused to complete the sales.
In a 21-page lawsuit filed last week in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, the developer charged that the owners have spurned its attempts to close on the properties and ignored a default notice.
Despite that notice, “the defendants have and continue to refuse to close on the Halket properties, unless Walnut Capital agrees to pay additional significant sums to defendants, which Walnut Capital is not contractually obligated to do,” the lawsuit stated.
The properties involved are located at 217, 219, 221, 223, 225, 227, 229, 231, 233, 235, 237, and 239 Halket.
Named as defendants in the lawsuit are Daniel and David Palmieri, Carmine Philip Casciato, Nicola K. Casciato, Daniel and Janet Casciato, Genesio and Diane Palmieri, Camillo and Aileen Palmieri, and Alfio A. and Anna Marie Pasquarelli.
Read More
Daniel Casciato declined comment on the lawsuit Thursday. He said the property owners first wanted to meet as a group to discuss it before saying anything.
According to an exhibit accompanying the lawsuit, the developer agreed to pay $1.35 million for each of the Halket properties, or $16.2 million in all.
Walnut Capital moved to acquire the houses, located between Forbes Avenue and Louisa Street, in 2021 as part of its proposed Oakland Crossings development, a massive venture targeting Central and South Oakland.
At the time, the proposal, since scaled back, included half a dozen apartment buildings and more than 1,000 units and a pedestrian bridge spanning the Boulevard of the Allies.
After the venture encountered opposition from some Oakland community groups, Walnut Capital reached a deal with Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey on a revised plan that totaled 13 acres instead of 17 and included fewer apartments.
However, the agreement kept in place a proposal to redevelop Halket across from UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital, where the developer is eyeing a possible combination of apartments and a hotel.
According to the lawsuit, Walnut Capital entered into a sales and purchase agreement with the owners of the Halket properties in July 2021 and agreed to close on them by Dec. 15 of the same year.
But it acknowledged in the complaint that it was unable to do so “due to delays beyond Walnut Capital’s control associated with the zoning changes” needed to advance the proposed redevelopment.
Those changes finally were approved by the city last June.
According to the lawsuit, none of the property owners issued a notice of default to Walnut Capital because of the failure to close by Dec. 15, 2021. As a result, the parties “remain bound by the terms and conditions set forth in the agreement of sale,” it stated.
But when Walnut Capital moved to close on the properties last Aug. 17, the defendants “ignored and/or refused to provide documents and/or information requested of them by the title company” to complete the transactions, the lawsuit maintained.
Nor did they attend the closing, it added. The defendants, the lawsuit claimed, also haven’t “cured” a notice of default sent to them demanding that they comply with the sales agreement and intent to close.
In the lawsuit, Walnut Capital argued that the Halket properties are “unique pieces of real estate” and an “integral component” of its larger plan to redevelop parts of Oakland.
It also stated that it had obtained favorable financing from Dollar Bank that is contingent on a timely closing.
“Due to the defendants’ conduct, it is apparent that they did not intend to honor the terms and conditions of the agreement of sale,” the lawsuit charged.
In accusing the property owners of a breach of contract, it is asking a judge to order the transfer of the properties with or without the defendants’ consent, along with payments from Walnut Capital for the agreed-upon purchase price.
However, those amounts could be reduced if a judge awards damages, as requested by Walnut Capital, based on money it has spent on engineering, design, and legal fees associated with the rezoning as well as legal fees spent on the lawsuit.
According to the litigation, Walnut Capital has shelled out more than $1 million on fees to facilitate the rezoning and to improve the Halket properties.
Another part of Walnut Capital’s ambitious Oakland Crossings plan includes the construction of a 426-unit apartment building and grocery at the former Quality Inn site bordering the lower part of Halket and the Boulevard of the Allies.
But the developer has put that project on hold as it wrestles with high construction costs, inflation and rising interest rates. None of the properties involved in the litigation are needed for that development.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.