More than six decades after it was forced off the land, Bethel AME Church could return to the former Civic Arena site as part of a proposed deal with the Pittsburgh Penguins.
The Rev. Dale B. Snyder, pastor of the Hill District church, said Wednesday that he hopes to finalize a memorandum of understanding with the team that would give Bethel AME the opportunity to develop up to 1.5 acres on the site.
“I think we’re close to an agreement. It’s just that we have to work out all of the details,” he said.
For more than a year, Rev. Snyder has been pushing the Penguins to return to the church the land it stood on from 1906 to 1957 before it was demolished to make way for the Civic Arena.
The Penguins balked, saying the property involved was partly beneath rebuilt Logan Street and partly beneath land that is designated for open space.
Under the deal being discussed, the Penguins have offered Bethel AME an alternative site of 1.5 acres at Wylie Avenue and Crawford Street – much larger than the original 13,100-square-foot church property.
Read More
While it’s a different site than that occupied by the original church, it does give the church a bigger footprint – about five times larger than the old Bethel AME property, Rev. Snyder said.
Although the two sides have tentatively agreed to the deal, he stressed there is still work to be done. Both have to finalize the MOU. He said he hopes to have that done soon.
“We’re close. I think we’re there but I don’t want to get ahead of it,” Rev. Snyder said. “I feel like we’re right at the goal line but we don’t have a touchdown yet.”
Details involving the proposed agreement were included in a letter the Penguins sent to the city planning commission Tuesday in conjunction with hearings on changes to a preliminary land development plan for the site and construction of a music venue and 910-space parking garage.
The team holds the development rights to the 28-acre former arena site, which is owned by the Sports & Exhibition Authority and the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority.
It had nothing to do with the taking of the church in 1957, an action carried out by the city to clear the Lower Hill for the Civic Arena development. The demolitions displaced thousands of people, most of them Black, and destroyed many businesses and cultural hubs.
In a statement Wednesday, Kevin Acklin, the Penguins’ president of business operations, said the team and developer Buccini Pollin Group are “excited to work with Bethel AME to pursue a restorative development together on the Lower Hill.”
“I think we need to work through final details, but the development team remains committed to a restorative redevelopment outcome with Bethel AME,” he added.
As part of its plan for the 1.5 acres, Bethel AME intends to return the church, now located on Webster Avenue, to the site, bringing a measure of redemption after being forced out in the name of urban renewal 66 years ago.
On top of the house of worship, Bethel AME, Pittsburgh’s oldest Black church, is planning to build housing, with 20% of it dedicated to low- and moderate-income families.
Describing the proposed development as “substantial,” Rev. Snyder said it would serve as a “national model for restorative justice.”
“It’s a historical moment. It’s a great win for the city of Pittsburgh,” he said.
In addition to the church and housing, the Bethel AME proposal calls for a daycare center and tutoring to help children learn to read and other skills.
The church is working with a co-developer, Rev. Snyder said.
Bethel AME traces its roots to 1808. It ran the first school to teach Black people to read and was involved in the women’s suffrage movement and other social justice causes.
The church moved to Wylie and Elm Street in 1845 after a fire. It erected a newer building with an 85-foot tower at the site in 1906 and stayed there until 1957.
Now it may have a chance to return, if not at the precise location, one that’s only a stone’s throw away – and larger, offering the opportunity to do even bigger things.
“”I’m just grateful for what God has done,” Rev. Snyder said. “Nobody but God could have pulled this all together.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.