An appeal by the Pittsburgh School District won’t stand in the way of a proposed deal that could result in tax breaks for thousands of Allegheny County homeowners involved in property assessment reviews.

Judge Alan Hertzberg ordered Allegheny County on Friday to turn over its conclusions related to a re-examination of the way it coded 2020 property sales data used as the basis for calculating assessments during appeal hearings this year.

The sales are used to determine what is known as the common level ratio, a state calculation applied in appeals to account for widening gaps between assessed values and current sales prices since the last countywide reassessment a decade ago.

The ratio is used to figure out the value at which a property will be taxed.

Advertise with us

For 2022, the county had intended to use 81.1%.

But it has been recalculating the number as part of an April consent agreement with nine property owners who filed a lawsuit claiming that the ratio was too high. Their attorney, John Silvestri, believes the new number could be as low as 64% when the county turns over its findings from the re-examination.

Mr. Silvestri feared that the final recalculation could be delayed after the school district last week appealed to the state’s Commonwealth Court a narrow issue related to the April consent agreement.

But in his ruling Friday, county Common Pleas Judge Hertzberg concluded that there is no reason to hold up the recalculation of the new ratio because of the appeal.

He said the district could appeal once the new number is released.

Advertise with us

As a result, he ordered the county to immediately share its data and conclusions with Mr. Silvestri, after which the two sides will present the findings to him.

A big drop in the common level ratio could produce significant savings for property owners who recently bought homes and are facing assessment appeals brought by school districts and municipalities.

For example, a house valued at $100,00 on appeal would be taxed at $81,100 using the 81.1% ratio. But if it falls to 64%, the property would be taxed at $64,000, a substantial savings.

A lower ratio also could trigger a slew of appeals from homeowners and commercial property owners looking to get a break on their taxes.

That could particularly be the case in 2023 when the ratio is already set to fall to 63.6%.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.