The Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment has rejected variances needed by a developer for a proposed seven-story, 10-unit condominium building in Shadyside, handing a major victory to residents who opposed the project.
In a 10-page decision issued Monday, the board ruled Artisan Development did not meet its burden under the zoning code to show the proposed variances would not “alter the essential character of the neighborhood” near the building at 316 S. Highland Ave.
It also concluded the concerns raised by residents related to the project height, setbacks and neighborhood impact were valid.
The board “found the outpouring of concerns and the well-articulated and well-supported descriptions of the detrimental impacts that would result from the combination of the requested variances ... to be both substantial and credible.”
Among the variances, Artisan had sought to increase the height of the development from the code limit of about 50 feet to 75 feet and to reduce required property setbacks from 25 feet to 5 feet.
But the board concluded the developer had not presented “any substantial evidence” to meet the burden of proof required to get the relief. It also found Artisan’s claims of hardship — a legal standard needed to get the variances — unpersuasive. It noted that the 60-foot property width Artisan had to work with was not unique in the city.
Read More
“It is a hardship only with respect to the magnitude of the development that the applicant proposes, not a hardship related to the property that precludes development of the site in accordance with the code’s site development standards,” the board stated.
It called the developer’s contention that the proposed 75-foot height would have limited impact on the surrounding neighborhood “self-serving and unsupported.”
The fact there are taller buildings on the opposite side of the street and nearby does not negate the impact the proposed development would have on its neighbors, the board stated.
Artisan originally wanted to build a nine-story, 19-unit building with a height of 85 feet at the site. It reduced the number of stories and units in an effort to win community support. It also planned to demolish an existing structure on the property.
Ryan Wotus, Artisan’s attorney, could not be reached for comment on the zoning board ruling.
Virginia Flaherty, a Shadyside resident who helped lead the fight against the proposed development, was thrilled with the decision.
“I’m just ecstatic about it,” she said. “I think it’s great. Hopefully, it will carry precedence with other developers who want to build these high-rise apartment buildings.”
Artisan also is pitching a plan for a six-story, 30-unit residential building at 5424 Kentucky Ave. in Shadyside, which has drawn neighborhood opposition.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.