Fresh off its $62.6 million rehab of the Strip District’s historic produce terminal, a Chicago developer is pitching a plan for a massive residential venture next to it.

Chicago-based McCaffery Interests is teaming with Pittsburgh-based Laurel Communities on the Brickworks — an eight-building development featuring 224 apartments and 60 townhouses on vacant land on Smallman Street across from the terminal.

The complex would be built on 3.5 acres of property that McCaffery acquired from New Jersey-based Rugby Realty for $19.5 million in 2020. It borders 21st, 23rd and Railroad streets. Part of it is next to St. Stanislaus Kostka Church.

Over the past two years, McCaffery had been considering a number of options for the site, from offices to townhouses to apartments and condominiums.

Advertise with us

In settling on apartments and townhomes, Dan McCaffery, CEO of McCaffery Interests, said the section of Smallman across from the church and the produce terminal appears to be a prime spot for residential development.

“That block, it feels residential to me, let me put it to you that way. It’s across the street from the church. It’s across from the Cork Factory. It just feels like residential is warranted,” he said.

The current proposal calls for eight structures in all. Two six-story buildings facing Smallman would feature apartments, each with 112 units.

Six others, ranging in size from four to six stories, would house for-sale townhomes. Two six-story structures each would have 20 townhouses and the other four would each hold five side-by-side units. All would be built on the Railroad Street side of the development.

The apartment mix would include studios and one- and two-bedroom units.

Advertise with us

Rents and prices have yet to be established.

Mr. McCaffery said the plans are still preliminary and could change.

“I can’t say we’re 100% sold on every aspect of the design. We will probably come up with some modifications as time goes on. But that’s a pretty good look at what’s on our minds today,” he said, referring to the current plan.

In proposing a residential development at the site, McCaffery is returning to its Strip roots. It was the lead developer behind the 2006 conversion of the former Armstrong Cork Factory into the 297-unit Cork Factory apartment complex, one it sold in 2014.

“I think the Strip was always kind of neat. We’ve provided a little bit of leadership showing that it is more than just a funky place. People have seen it for what it is and have said, ‘Hey, I want to live there,’” he said.

Advertise with us

These days, the Strip is awash in residential development. One of the big players has been Laurel Communities, which has built more than 40 luxury for-sale townhouses behind the produce terminal ranging in price from $650,000 to $1.3 million.

In all, in 2021, the Strip was home to 1,425 rental and condo units, with another 730 being built and 530 planned, according to a report by the Strip District Neighbors community group.

Of course, Mr. McCaffery believes there’s a market for more.

“There’s room for more residential in the city of Pittsburgh because people are liking moving to cities now, younger people, and the Strip is just one of the areas people are enjoying,” he said.

Even before its latest venture, McCaffery was bullish enough on city residential trends to purchase last year the 18-story, 151-unit Encore on 7th apartment complex in Downtown.

Advertise with us

Mr. McCaffery said he would like to get started on the new Strip development as soon as possible.

The developer has submitted plans for the project to the city. It is seeking several zoning variances related to the work. A hearing date has yet to be set.

While the proposed complex spans several acres, Mr. McCaffery said he would prefer to build it all at once with some general phasing to account for the construction.

“My preference by a large margin is to get it going and completed,” he said.

McCaffery borrowed the Brickworks name from Rugby Realty, which had plans for an $80 million office and retail development at the site called the Brickworks at 21st and Smallman.

Advertise with us

Rugby had received city planning commission approval for the proposal, which would have been built in two phases, before selling the property to McCaffery. The site once housed produce wholesaler Tom Ayoob Inc., Acme Banana Co., and Benkovitz Seafoods.

In addition to the produce terminal rehab, McCaffery converted a warehouse across the street at 1600 Smallman into offices, with autonomous vehicle firm Aurora Innovation taking all of the space.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.