More than a decade after a developer first advanced plans for a hotel, a prime piece of Downtown real estate continues to sit vacant after the latest deal for the site collapsed.
Parkway Corp., a Philadelphia-based parking operator and developer, bailed out in December after its rights to purchase the property, located on Ross Street between Third and Fourth avenues, expired.
It did so after the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment denied variances that would have allowed the developer to use the land for parking for five to eight years while it came up with a redevelopment plan for the site.
Parkway was in the middle of an appeal of the zoning board’s decision when its purchase rights expired. At that point, it withdrew the appeal.
Since then the fenced-in lot — which for years was used by Allegheny County to park cars — has remained vacant. It is owned by Ross Hospitality Associates LP, an affiliate of Kratsa Properties, which once had plans to build a 156-room, six-story hotel there.
The parcel is one of the few vacant sites left for potential redevelopment left in Downtown, where more than a decade of building has left land scarce. But so far no one has seized the opportunity.
Read More
Months after withdrawing the appeal, Robert Zuritsky, Parkway’s president and chief executive officer, is still bitter about the zoning board’s handling of the variance requests.
“We spent a lot of time and a lot of money,” he said. “The city rejected our concept. We have walked away very, very disappointed.”
Parkway wanted to operate a parking lot with about 67 spaces at the site. It needed a variance because surface parking is not a permitted use in the Golden Triangle zoning district.
At the time, Mr. Zuritsky described the proposed parking as a “temporary carry” until Parkway came up with a better plan for the site. Options ran the gamut from residential to office to hotel.
While the company is known primarily as a parking operator, it also has branched out into development, particularly in its hometown, where its projects have included offices, hotels, and residential buildings.
In Pittsburgh, it currently operates one garage, according to its website.
The three-member zoning board, in its decision, seemed to be wary about granting a parking variance for an indefinite period.
“The applicant did not attempt to assert that any unique condition of the site created an unnecessary hardship that precluded the use of the property for any of the variety of uses permitted in the GT-B District,” it wrote.
“Instead, the applicant maintained that the property’s use as a commercial parking lot would be appropriate until some indefinite time in the future when the owner might decide that the time is right to proceed with development for a permitted use.”
Mr. Zuritsky noted that the county had used the lot for parking in the past. It did so from 2012 until the end of 2017 when it moved vehicles to a lot at the far east end of Fourth that once was the site for the county parking garage, which was demolished.
“We just wanted to open it up to the public and start paying taxes on it,” he said.
But Mr. Zuritsky insisted that the plan was for the parking to be temporary.
“In the last five years, we’ve built apartments. We just opened a hotel a month ago. We’re working on office and residential,” he said. “We’re pretty active developers. We’ve been in Pittsburgh for over 30 years and we were very saddened by the whole transaction.”
Kratsa did not return a phone call seeking an update on the status of the site.
Its affiliate, Ross Hospitality, paid $1.5 million in 2007 to buy the property from the county. At the time, it unveiled a plan for the six-story hotel with a 100-space underground parking garage. The project never advanced.
At one time, the lot housed the 274-cell jail annex, constructed in the former Jones Law Building at a cost of $11.8 million. It had opened in 1986 to ease crowding at the old county jail. The annex closed in 1995 and was razed in 2003.
The old parking lot is not the only one in Downtown that has been eyed for potential redevelopment.
In 2017, InterPark Holdings, a Chicago company that owns a 1.79-acre parking lot on Grant Street across from the City-County Building, sought a partner interested in transforming that site into a major new mixed-use development.
To date, no redevelopment has occurred. Gerry Dudley, a CBRE executive vice president who was helping InterPark in its search for a partner, could not be reached for comment.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.
Corrected, posted Oct. 17, 2019: The description of the location of the vacant lot has been corrected.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.