Walnut Capital has won a key victory in its bid to erect a new building on Fifth Avenue in Oakland dubbed the innovation research tower.

The Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment has approved variances and a special exception that gives the Shadyside developer the right to build to 10 stories or 152 feet at the corner of Halket Street and to limit the amount of parking to 100 spaces.

Without the approvals, Walnut Capital would have been restricted to an 85-foot height under the city’s zoning code or 120 feet with just a special exception. The code also requires 299 parking spaces for such a development.

In a ruling issued Thursday, zoning board members LaShawn Burton-Faulk and John J. Richardson concluded that the proposed development near Carlow University was consistent with the context of the surrounding neighborhood, including the 10-story SkyVue apartment complex adjacent to the site.

Advertise with us

They also decided that the development would not cause negative impacts because of the efforts by Walnut Capital to improve the public realm and to accommodate neighborhood concerns.

“Finally, the applicant credibly demonstrated that variances requested represent the minimum relief needed to make development of the site feasible given the unique site conditions,” they wrote.

Zoning board chairwoman Alice B. Mitinger recused herself from the decision.

During a March 14 zoning board hearing, representatives of Walnut Capital had argued that because of the irregular shape and topography of the site the 10-story height was needed to make the development financially feasible.

Todd Reidbord, Walnut Capital president, said the company was pleased with the decision. It will allow the firm to offer enough space to potential research partners with UPMC, the University of Pittsburgh or others.

Advertise with us

“We believe this will be the first real significant building to be built as part of the new Oakland innovation zone,” he said.

While Walnut Capital cleared a significant hurdle with the zoning board ruling, the proposed development still must be approved by the city planning commission.

Walnut Capital hopes to start construction in February and have the building completed by spring 2022.

As currently envisioned, the structure will feature 280,000 square feet of office space and 6,000 square feet of first floor retail on Fifth. The design will be flexible enough to allow for creation of “light lab space” for companies that want it, Mr. Reidbord said.

Walnut Capital also is proposing 5,101 square feet of public open space along Fifth and Halket frontages. As part of its plan, a series of one- and two-story buildings located at the site would be demolished.

Advertise with us

The zoning board approved the variances and special exception contingent on the developer complying with a community benefits agreement reached with the Oakland Planning and Development Corp. and a traffic demand management initiative.

Under the community benefits deal, Walnut Capital will provide 4,500 square feet of retail space at the Fifth Avenue site to the development corporation at $1 a year to lease to locally-owned businesses.

In addition, it is giving the Oakland organization a $250,000 no-interest loan for its affordable housing trust fund and a $40,000 grant to help administer the loan fund. Both match commitments by UPMC and Pitt, according to Walnut Capital.

Wanda Wilson, Oakland Planning and Development Corp. executive director, declined comment on the zoning board ruling, saying she had yet to read it. The development corporation had submitted a letter of support for the development, contingent on a commitment to the community benefits agreement.

Walnut Capital also has agreed to the creation of a traffic demand management plan to address concerns about parking.

Advertise with us

Under that initiative, it must put together strategies such as car pooling, public transit, bicycling or walking to try to limit the number of vehicles entering Oakland and to avoid increasing congestion.

“You have to make a difference in getting people to the building without driving a single occupancy vehicle,” Ms. Wilson said.

Walnut Capital had been considering as many as 12 stories at the Fifth Avenue site but reduced it to 10 after discussions with OPDC and other stakeholders.

During the March hearing, three Oakland residents who lived within a mile of the proposed site raised objections. They cited concerns about height, massing, loss of views, traffic, parking, and the impact on the neighborhood’s character.

The zoning board found those concerns “to be speculative in nature and insufficient to meet the heavy burden of demonstrating that any impacts from the proposed use would somehow abnormally affect the public interest.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.