The Pittsburgh Penguins’ latest vision for redeveloping the former Civic Arena site will come at a cost — the elimination of 2,500 surface parking spaces now used by fans and commuters.

It’s a predicament the Steelers and Pirates have faced on the North Shore, and one that the Penguins already are working to deal with in the lower Hill District and beyond.

They hope to soften the blow to fans, commuters and others by building at least one new garage on the arena site and by teaming with UPMC Mercy hospital and Duquesne University to create a broader parking district to ensure there will be spaces available to meet demand.

There could even be signs and apps employed to direct motorists to available parking spaces not only at the arena site but to other spots in parts of Uptown, the Bluff and the lower Hill.

Advertise with us

“The overall message is that we are approaching this in a comprehensive way,” said Kevin Acklin, the Penguins senior vice president spearheading the arena development.

Through the Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority, which owns part of the arena site, the Penguins have applied for a $12 million state capital grant to help build a parking garage to replace some of the 2,500 surface spaces that could be lost to development.

The current thinking is that the garage would hold about 900 to 1,000 spaces and would be built in the middle of the 28-acre lower Hill site, near the Interstate 279 HOV lanes.

Under the hockey team’s agreement with the URA and the Sports & Exhibition Authority — the other owner of the arena site — there is a commitment to build a garage to replace lost spaces.

But the garage itself will not replace all 2,500 spaces. That’s where the parking district comes into play.

Advertise with us
(Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The goal is not only to create a broader inventory that would count lots and garages in the vicinity but to incorporate pedestrian upgrades and public transit — particularly given the plan to create a bus rapid transit system to run along Forbes and Fifth avenues near the arena.

“Let’s use this as an opportunity to rethink this whole area as a district,” Mr. Acklin said.

The Penguins and development partners Buccini/Pollin Group and Intergen have hired consultant Trans Associates to conduct a comprehensive parking, traffic, and pedestrian study.

That will include an assessment of the expected demand generated by development on the arena site, as well as by PPG Paints Arena, Duquesne University, and UPMC Mercy.

The Penguins also intend to talk to Alco Parking, one of the city’s largest private operators, and the city’s parking authority to determine the amount of parking they have available and where.

Advertise with us

Once the study has been completed, the team will meet with the city in a bid to come up with “the best overall mobility plan” for the district, Mr. Acklin said.

“In effect, the Penguins are taking a broader approach to finding multimodal mobility solutions for the entire arena district as a testament to our commitment as responsible developers for the city and entire region,” he said.

The team also would like to make it easier for pedestrians to navigate the intersection at Centre Avenue and Washington Place near one of the PPG Paints Arena’s main entrances.

Boundaries for the proposed parking district would be established once the Trans Associates has been completed. However, they are expected to include a new 1,000-space garage slated to be built at UPMC Mercy as well as additional garages located in Downtown.

As for the new garage at the arena site, Mr. Acklin said it “might be something that we build or the public will build.”

Advertise with us

On the North Shore, the SEA and the city’s Stadium Authority were responsible for building the 1,300-space, $28 million West General Robinson Street Garage and the 998-space, $22 million Gold 1 Garage to replace spaces lost to development.

As surface spaces at the former arena site are removed for development, another issue that will have to be addressed is how to make up for a parking surcharge levied to support a capital reserve fund to maintain and improve PPG Paints Arena. The surcharge is part of the parking fee paid by drivers.

The first $400,000 of that surcharge now goes into the fund. Anything beyond that is retained by the Penguins.

One of the goals of the Trans study, Mr. Acklin said, is to preserve and enhance that revenue stream for the arena.

As the arena site is developed, the Penguins will lose the parking revenue they receive from the spaces. The team also collects revenue from a 500-space garage next to PPG Paints Arena.

Advertise with us

Parking has been a contentious issue at the site. As development has stalled in the past, some activists maintained that the team would rather collect the revenue than build — an assertion the Penguins have repeatedly denied.

“The Penguins are seeking to complete the development and create an exciting new center of energy for the region, not stay in the parking business,” Mr. Acklin said.

The team will lose the rights to the arena’s surface parking revenue in October 2023. At that point, any revenue from spaces that haven’t been developed will go to the SEA or URA.

Plans for the arena site now include 1,420 units of housing, 810,000 square feet of office space, 190,000 square feet of retail, a 50,000-square-foot music venue, a 220-room hotel, and a 10,000-square-foot food hall spread over 28 acres.

Construction of the first 274 units of housing are expected to start in the fall, followed in the winter by the development of a 200,000-square-foot office building with 50,000 square feet of retail.

Advertise with us

The Penguins already have signed Punch Bowl Social, an entertainment and dining destination, to occupy 23,000 square feet of space over two floors as part of that development.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.