Two Democratic leaders of the Pennsylvania Senate are ripping a proposal by state House Speaker Mike Turzai to give the Legislature and governor influence over the Allegheny County Airport Authority board.

Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, and Democratic Caucus Chair Wayne Fontana of Brookline questioned the motives behind the Republican’s proposal to expand the board from nine to 13 members, with five appointed by the state.

“I think it’s ridiculous. It’s not needed,” Mr. Fontana said.

“That’s not the way to do it by adding more representatives or senators or whoever to the board. I think they’re doing a great job as it is. You got to question the motives. What’s the real reason behind it?”

Advertise with us

All nine of the authority board members are now appointed by county Executive Rich Fitzgerald. Under Mr. Turzai’s legislation, Mr. Fitzgerald would lose one appointment. Five members would be appointed by the state — one by each of the legislative caucuses and one by the governor.

In an interview Monday, Mr. Turzai, of Bradford Woods, maintained he had only one motive in mind in pitching the legislation.

“It’s good government. It’s checks and balances,” he said.

Besides receiving $12.4 million annually from the state to help reduce costs to the airlines operating from Pittsburgh International Airport, the authority has received tens of millions of dollars more in recent years in state capital grant and Department of Transportation funding, Mr. Turzai said.

He suspects that the airport authority will be turning to the state again for funding as it prepares to embark on a $1.1 billion modernization project at Pittsburgh International Airport.

Advertise with us

Given that, the state should have some representation on the board, he argued. It’s no different, he said, than the legislation passed in 2013 that expanded the Port Authority board from nine to 11 members, with four appointed by the General Assembly and one by the governor.

“Nine members [appointed] by the county executive, that doesn’t seem right. They’re always coming to the state for money. The airport authority is always coming from the state for money,” he said.

Mr. Turzai said his bill is bipartisan in nature in that two of the state appointees would come from the Democratic caucuses and two would come from the Republican caucuses. The other would be made by Democratic governor Tom Wolf.

All of the legislative appointees would have to be Allegheny County residents, he said. They would not necessarily have to be legislators. There is no residency requirement for the governor’s appointee, he said.

The airport authority has been receiving $12.4 million a year from the state for the last decade. Through Mr. Costa’s efforts, the allocation from the slots-backed state economic development fund was reauthorized in 2017 as part of the gambling expansion.

Advertise with us

Mr. Costa and Mr. Fontana questioned the timing of Mr. Turzai’s proposal, particularly with the modernization project getting ready to take off.

“The timing of this, all of the sudden there’s a focus on the airport authority and there’s a big project. You have to wonder. Connect the dots,” Mr. Fontana said.

“[Mr. Turzai] certainly wants to have input on members of the board. What does that say? The timing, it seems to me, he wants to have input over the project.”

Mr. Turzai said he doesn’t have an opinion on the project itself, “but I do think there should be a good government system of checks and balances.”

Regarding funding, Mr. Costa said there’s a big difference in what the airport authority gets from the state as opposed to the Port Authority, which receives hundreds of millions of dollars in state operating and capital funding each year.

Advertise with us

He also worried about the ramifications for other local authorities.

“This could set a bad precedent. Are we going to do this to any type of authority that gets state funding? Are we going to restructure other boards?” he asked.

The airport authority and Mr. Fitzgerald’s office have declined comment on the legislation.

Mr. Turzai shrugged off the criticism from the two Democratic senators. Having all of the appointees selected by the county executive, he suggested, doesn’t make for good oversight.

“I do not understand what their complaint is unless it’s a completely political position, which would not surprise me from Sen. Costa and Sen. Fontana,” he said.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Fontana insisted there is already oversight through county council, through audits and even through the procedures the authority has to follow to get state grants.

As for the legislation itself, Mr. Turzai said he is open to alternatives, such as a nine-member board with two of the appointees coming from the state.

“I think our proposal is the best because it follows an existing paradigm and is bipartisan, but we’re open to other suggestions,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.