The owner of U.S. Steel Tower is su­ing the Red the Steak­house, seek­ing to re­cover $4.4 mil­lion in back rent and other pay­ments tied to the Down­town restau­rant’s clos­ing in Sep­tem­ber.

In the law­suit filed Thurs­day in Al­le­gheny County Com­mon Pleas Court, 600 GS Prop LP ac­cuses the steak­house of de­fault­ing on rent pay­ments and fail­ing to pay con­trac­tor A. Mar­tini & Co. all amounts owed re­lated to the con­struc­tion of its nearly 10,000-square-foot space on the build­ing’s first floor.

Named as de­fen­dants are Red Pitts­burgh LLC, Red Down­town LLC, and BJPM Ltd.

Ac­cord­ing to the law­suit, Red owes $251,940 in back rent and $648,243 to A. Mar­tini & Co. The U.S. Steel Tower owner also is seek­ing $3.5 mil­lion in ac­cel­er­ated rent pay­ments due from Oct. 1 to the end of the 10-year lease.

Advertise with us

It stated that the steak­house, which opened in Oc­to­ber 2017, missed sev­eral rent pay­ments af­ter oc­cu­py­ing the space and was sent a no­tice of de­fault in July.

On Aug. 31, 600 GS Prop then sent a no­tice ter­mi­nat­ing the lease, ef­fec­tive Sept. 7, af­ter Brad Fried­lander, an Ohioan who is CEO of the restau­rant chain, wrote a let­ter Aug. 24 stat­ing that “we will have to close Red Pitts­burgh.”

In an Aug. 29 email that was in­cluded in one of the at­tach­ments to the com­plaint, Mr. Fried­lander ad­dressed the is­sues with the restau­rant.

“As we do not have fi­nan­cial sta­bil­ity at this time and are pre­par­ing to take ac­tions clos­ing other units, we can­not in good faith com­mit to a pay­ment plan given the poor per­for­mance of the lo­ca­tion,” he wrote.

“We are cer­tainly sorry this turned out this way. [H]ow­ever, based on the ma­jor losses al­ready suf­fered and the dev­as­tat­ing im­pact that has had on the en­tire or­ga­ni­za­tion, we do not have any op­tions.”

Advertise with us

In an in­ter­view, Mr. Fried­lander at­trib­uted the restau­rant’s prob­lems to be­ing un­der­cap­i­tal­ized.

“I love Pitts­burgh. I can’t tell you how sad we are in what hap­pened in our sit­u­a­tion there,” he said. “We thought we had some fund­ing that we didn’t have and that led to our de­mise.”

Mr. Fried­lander said it was par­tic­u­larly up­set­ting for him be­cause his father at­tended Schen­ley High School and ran a con­ces­sion at the Civic Arena af­ter it opened in 1961.

“Be­cause I have roots in Pitts­burgh, it sad­dens me even more,” he said.

Mr. Fried­lander also said he has had to close an In­di­a­nap­o­lis restau­rant. Two of his restau­rants in Cleve­land, one a Red the Steak­house and an­other called Moxie, are in Chap­ter 11 bank­ruptcy, he added.

Advertise with us

Stan­ley Parker, the at­tor­ney rep­re­sent­ing 600 GS Prop, could not be reached for com­ment re­gard­ing the Pitts­burgh com­plaint.

Ac­cord­ing to the law­suit, 600 GS Prop is pay­ing the $648,243 owed to A. Mar­tini to avoid hav­ing a lien placed on the U.S. Steel build­ing. As a re­sult, it “is en­ti­tled to pur­sue the col­lec­tion” of the pay­ment from Red Pitts­burgh, the com­plaint stated.

Be­fore clos­ing, Red the Steak­house was one of at least 10 steak­houses in Down­town. But Mr. Fried­lander re­fused to blame the num­ber for his restau­rant’s fail­ings.

“I don’t think that was our di­rect is­sue. We weren’t the best we could be be­cause we didn’t have the funds,” he said. “We fell short on ev­ery level and we failed the cus­tomer.”

The 200-seat Pitts­burgh restau­rant was open less than a year be­fore clos­ing. The show­case or­der was a 40-day dry-aged 16-ounce prime rib-eye priced at $61.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-ga­zette.com or 412-263-1262.