The Pittsburgh Parking Authority is moving ahead with plans to demolish and replace an old 586-space garage at Ninth Street and Penn Avenue, Downtown — even as it still holds out hope for a much broader development at the site.
Authority officials on Monday issued a request for proposals for construction management and architectural design services for the demolition of the current garage, and for the building of a new one with at least 600 spaces.
But that does not mean the authority has given up on efforts to do a much bigger development at the location, potentially incorporating residential, retail or other concepts, executive director David Onorato said.
In fact, Mr. Onorato said The Davis Companies of Boston and the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust once again are talking about a possible condominium and retail development at the site after negotiations appeared to have collapsed in May.
The project, he said, would be essentially the same as the earlier one — up to 185 high-end condos built over four phases and 30,000 square feet of street-level retail in addition to a new garage, all at a cost of about $175 million.
As a result, the authority is “not closing out on the option” of a broader development at this point, Mr. Onorato said.
Read More
“I guess there’s always hope as long as it’s still open,” he said of the talks. “That’s how I look at it.”
Jonathan Davis, The Davis Companies CEO and founder, said any discussions with the trust “are too premature to comment on.”
“It’s obviously an exciting piece of real estate that offers a lot of opportunities,” he said.
Kevin McMahon, the trust’s CEO and president, declined comment.
The project appeared to be dead in May when the trust, which owns several of the parcels needed for the development, ended negotiations with The Davis Companies after nearly a year of talks.
At issue at the time was the phasing of the redevelopment. The Davis Companies wanted to do a $40 million first phase that would have involved about 30 condos and street-level retail built around a new 935-space garage.
But the trust wanted the firm to erect another 80-unit condo tower at the same time — a risk that The Davis Companies was uncomfortable taking. It wanted to see how the first units did before building more.
Mr. Onorato said the authority decided to issue the request for proposals related to the demolition of the old garage and the construction of the new one so it would be prepared if talks on a broader development fizzle out again.
Under the current timetable, the authority board is expected to award the construction management and architectural design services contracts in November.
While Mr. Onorato isn’t counting out a bigger project at the site, the authority, in the RFPs, states that it “desires to demolish the existing garage as soon as reasonably possible and move to construction immediately thereafter.”
The current garage, opened in 1958, is said to be in poor shape. In May, Dan Gilman, chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto, said it needed about $100,000 in short-term repairs just to keep it operating.
But Mr. Onorato said the garage, based on structural reports, is fine. It will be re-evaluated quarterly “just to be proactive,” he added.
At this point, Mr. Onorato said he doesn’t see the need for any short-term fixes. The authority doesn’t want to be in the position of throwing good money after bad “because we know it is coming down,” he said, referring to the demolition.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.