It’s a neighborhood with so many distinctions that University of Pittsburgh population researcher Christopher Briem even has a phrase for it — “Squirrel Hill Exceptionalism.”

Squirrel Hill has long been among the Pittsburgh’s largest, most densely populated and highest educated neighborhoods. Many streets are lined with closely huddled, one-family brick homes and other residences that range from mansions to apartment complexes and newer developments.

Its housing market held its own even in the depth of the Great Recession a decade ago and now is marked by strong demand.

But the community strengths that protected Squirrel Hill from the economic downturn are now creating another challenge — threatening to send home prices so high that its diverse population may struggle to keep finding affordable homes there.

Advertise with us

At the moment, despite a more than 40 percent increase in average home prices since 2008, the community has hung onto the religious, ethnic and, to some extent, economic diversity that proves attractive to many newcomers.

Squirrel Hill has retained its historic role as the hub of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community even as that community spreads out from that base. The familiar scenes of men in black suits and women in long dresses headed to synagogues or to Murray Avenue Kosher are juxtaposed with newer ones, such as a Lunar New Year parade in March featuring a lion dance by Chinese-American youth and a procession of Bhutanese refugees waving miniature American flags.

“What I’ve noticed is remarkable stability in a lot of ways in Squirrel Hill,” said Pittsburgh City Council member Erika Strassburger, recently elected to represent District 8, which includes much of the neighborhood.

“It harkens back to another time” of walkable, front-porch neighborhoods near stores, restaurants and bus lines. “You haven’t seen major developments or façade changes that could make it look like Anywhere, USA.”

Enter our In the Lead special section

Advertise with us

In contrast to the thickly settled streets, the large Frick and Schenley parks bracketing the neighborhood provide a venue for sledders, joggers and the neighborhood’s eponymous gray squirrels. Local boosters, in between hyping such things as convenient bus lines and an array of solid private and public schools, like to point out that Squirrel Hill was the real-life Fred “Mister” Rogers’ neighborhood.

The community stands out for its large student population, particularly in Squirrel Hill North (one of two neighborhoods officially recognized by Pittsburgh, although most people think of Squirrel Hill as a single unit).

And largely due to those drawn to Pittsburgh to study, teach or otherwise work at the eds and meds of nearby Oakland or Downtown, the neighborhood has a remarkably high proportion of people who aren’t from around here.

The proportion of residents born outside of Pennsylvania — and outside the country — is much higher than the city overall. The 61C bus, which wades through the main arteries of Forbes and Murray avenues at regular intervals on its way between the Mon Valley and Downtown, may enclose the most diverse, polyglot collection of people in Pittsburgh, said Mr. Briem, of Pitt’s University Center for Social and Urban Research.

Squirrel Hill North and South combined have about 27,000 residents, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s most recent estimate. It’s about 80 percent white, 3 percent black and 14 percent Asian. The Asian population is up significantly in the past few years, evidenced by dozens of new Chinese and other South and East Asian restaurants and business.

Advertise with us

Still, Squirrel Hill retains its historically strong Jewish presence.

A report published earlier this year by Brandeis University researchers found that Squirrel Hill, home to numerous synagogues and other Jewish institutions, still has about 30 percent of the region’s Jewish population — even as that growing population fans out to adjacent city neighborhoods and the suburbs.

The report, conducted on behalf of the Jewish Community Foundation of Greater Pittsburgh, estimated there were nearly 15,000 Jews living either in Squirrel Hill or close by.

Orthodox Jews, with their distinctive dress and observances, are a visible presence in the neighborhood, where they have close access to synagogues, Jewish schools, a kosher market and a mikvah for ritual bathing.

But Jews of all denominations as well as those more focused on culture than religion are here: The report found that Squirrel Hill had exceptionally high rates of religious observance, raising of children in the faith and involvement at the Jewish Community Center.

Advertise with us

Still, the pricey housing is prompting some Jewish families, and others, to begin settling in Greenfield and other nearby neighborhoods — if not moving farther out to the North or South Hills.

An average home price in 2017 in Pittsburgh’s 14th Ward, which overlaps with Squirrel Hill and surrounding neighborhoods, was at $398,756, according to RealSTATs, a Ross-based real estate information service.

That’s up 42 percent from $281,185 in the recessionary nadir of 2008 — the seventh-highest dollar increase of any neighborhood or municipality in Allegheny County.

“Even during the recession in the middle of 2008, we were still stable,” said real estate agent Sherri Mayer of Howard Hanna. “Squirrel Hill is like a world within its own world.”

She said today it’s common for a seller to receive multiple offers on the first weekend of house showings.

Advertise with us

“It’s crazy right now,” Ms. Mayer said. “We have zero inventory.”

Prices range widely, she added, depending on the house and the street,

“I’m parked in front of a house at $270,000,” she said by cell phone. “If you go around the corner from here, four houses are at $600,000. If you go in the other direction, they’re over a million.”

Marian Lien, executive director of the Squirrel Hill Urban Coalition, which has long worked to steer the neighborhood’s development, said, “Everybody deserves to be close to such wonderful amenities.”

She added: “The biggest challenge will be ensuring the middle income rentals and home prices remain stable so there is always that option for the couple or the family buying their first home in Squirrel Hill if that’s where they want to live.”

Advertise with us

Just because Squirrel Hill is “known as the higher socio-economic neighborhood in the city, it doesn’t mean you can’t build in some economic diversity, too,” she said.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.