There’s still high demand for a full-service grocery and a Target discount department store Downtown, according to results from a new survey of residents and pedestrians in the Golden Triangle. But try as developers may, it doesn’t look like anyone should bank on seeing either any time soon.

A full-service grocery topped the list of desired retail amenities in the survey conducted by the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership and released this week. The two groups also would like to see a discount/mass retail chain move in, with Target being number one on the list.

It’s not a new refrain and local developers have been courting a full-service grocery and a Target to fill spaces Downtown for years.

But so far, their efforts haven’t panned out, even though the residential population continues to grow. Overall, 4,852 people lived Downtown last year, up 33.7 percent from 2010, according to the PDP.

Advertise with us

For the last three years, Highwoods Properties, the owner of PPG Place, has been trying to recruit a grocery to the former lower level food court space in Two PPG Place. Andy Wisniewski, Highwoods vice president in Pittsburgh, said the company hasn’t given up.

“We’re still hopeful. We do think somebody will see this opportunity and take advantage of it. I think the group that does that will put themselves in a prime position in the city of Pittsburgh. It will be welcomed. It will be highly successful and it will leave others wishing they had done the same,” he said.

The East End Food Co-Op, a Point Breeze natural and organic food market, at one point considered the space. No deal materialized.

Mr. Wisniewski would not disclose other grocers he had talked to but said the main drawbacks they cited included not having a similar model with which to compare the space. “It’s an urban footprint that doesn’t follow their standard footprint,” he said.

Giant Eagle scouted potential locations for a store Downtown several years ago, but nothing ever came of it. In a statement Friday, Dan Donovan, Giant Eagle director of corporate communications, said the O’Hara grocer remains “intrigued by the city’s ongoing population growth and commercial development.”

Advertise with us

Millcraft Investments also considered a grocery in the redevelopment of the former Saks Fifth Avenue department store site, which is being converted into a mixed use project including a parking garage and retail, residential and hotel space.

Herky Pollock, CBRE executive vice president and a prominent retail real estate broker in the city, said one drawback has been that proposed deals “had to be heavily subsidized by the landlord, which in some cases included free parking, which made the deal cost prohibitive.”

Lucas Piatt, Millcraft president and chief operating officer, said rent requirements and parking were issues at the Saks site on Smithfield Street.

Another Downtown developer, McKnight Realty Partners, has been trying to interest Target and discount fashion retailers Ross Dress for Less and T.J. Maxx in the 19,000-square-foot former Office Depot space in the former Gimbels department store building on Smithfield Street.

So far there have been no takers.

Advertise with us

“We continue to see strong interest in retail given that it is the largest retail space in the Downtown area. We just don’t have any signed deals to report,” said Izzy Rudolph, a McKnight principal.

McKnight also has talked to national grocers. “They’re all interested but they would like to see more rooftops in the area before they commit,” Mr. Rudolph said. By rooftops, he’s referring to residences.

The same issue apparently has hampered the efforts to recruit Target or other retailers.

It doesn’t mean a grocery or a Target-like store won’t ever happen. Mr. Pollock said Minnesota-based Target just announced plans to aggressively expand its smaller format Target Express concept. “To me Downtown Pittsburgh would be an ideal opportunity for them to locate one of those stores,” he said.

The grocery might be a little tougher, but not impossible.

Advertise with us

“I think there’s enough density to warrant a grocery store. However, the stars need to be aligned to make it happen — the right location, ample parking nearby and ease of access,” Mr. Pollock said.

Downtown residents currently have access to a market in Market Square as well as a number of drug stores that stock household staples. There’s also a Shop ‘n Save in the Hill District.

And if there can’t be a Target Downtown, maybe there will be one on the North Side.

Mr. Piatt said Millcraft is considering a Target-like store among the mix of amenities it is planning for its Chateau Landing project to be built on 13 acres of former industrial property.

The ambitious project could involve retail, restaurants, a large marina, a hotel, an entertainment district, and possibly offices. Mr. Piatt noted that there really are no large discount/mass retail chains along the Route 65 corridor between the North Side and Sewickley.

Advertise with us

As for the potential for a Target at his site, “I think that would be great,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.