A local developer advanced plans Tuesday for the construction of a new 50,000-square-foot Whole Foods Market at the site of a former East Liberty apartment building, but there still may be changes needed to bring the project to reality.
At a briefing, city planning commission members raised concerns about some aspects of the project, as did a neighborhood group opposed to a proposal to vacate a street that would be relocated under the plan presented by LG Realty Advisors.
The grocery is meant to be part of a larger development known as East Liberty Marketplace that would include about 200 apartments, 12,000 square feet of office space and 582 parking spaces.
It would be built on land that once was part of Penn Plaza apartments, where more than 100 residents — many of them older and with low incomes — have been relocated to make way for the development project.
As part of the plan, Downtown-based LG Realty is proposing to vacate Eva Street and relocate it closer to Penn Avenue to maintain the 2.2 acres of Enright Park, as required under a zoning change approved in April. The park sits behind Penn Plaza apartments.
In a memo to planning commission members, the Enright Park Neighborhood Association and East Liberty community stakeholders called the proposal “unacceptable,” saying that it “cuts off a vital access route for the neighborhood and is an inappropriate design solution.”
Read More
But Jonathan Kamin, attorney for LG Realty, said the relocation was contemplated as part of the conditions attached to the zoning change approved in April and it allows the developer to maintain the full 2.2 acres of the park. He said LG Realty is giving up more than 11,000 square feet of its property to put in the new street.
Despite the disagreement, Mr. Kamin is still hopeful an accommodation can be reached before commission members are scheduled to vote on the preliminary land development plan in two weeks.
“We’ve been working hard with them. They’ve been tough negotiators. We’re hopeful that we can come to an agreement but it has to be driven by the data in terms of what we can do,” he said.
Even if he cannot get a deal, Mr. Kamin said the proposal, as currently constituted, meets all of the requirements ordered by council in granting the zoning change last spring and should be approved by the commission.
“From an objective view, we meet all of the criteria. Now we’d like to have everybody’s support to be able to make life easier,” he said.
Commission members raised some of their own concerns about the proposal, Member Jean Holland Dick took issue with the lack of affordable housing in the apartment plans.
While Mr. Kamin acknowledged that there would be none, he pointed out LG Realty has agreed to commit 50 percent of the tax increments from the redevelopment to a fund set aside for affordable housing. He estimates that will generate about $12 million.
Other members raised concerns about the safety of pedestrians crossing Penn Avenue once the new Whole Foods opens and asked whether existing crosswalks would be sufficient. Mr. Kamin said the development team will work on safety enhancements to address such concerns.
At 50,000 square feet, the new Whole Foods would be nearly double the size of the existing East Liberty store on Centre Avenue. Mr. Kamin said commission approval is needed to move ahead with the project.
As part of the redevelopment plan, offices would be located on a second floor above the Whole Foods. Apartments would be built on top of the parking garage to the south of the store.
Construction is expected to start in the first quarter of 2017. Whole Foods has not stated what will become of the existing grocery store.
Although one Penn Plaza apartment building has been demolished to make way for the development, a second still remains. All residents are supposed to be out of that building by March.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.