In the end, it came down to the proverbial “lesser of two evils.”

Ross commissioners Monday, in identical 5-3 votes, approved a site plan and two variances for The Ridge at Highland Pines, an 85-unit townhouse development in the Buckhill Road area after a three-hour public hearing.

The variances were needed to comply with a township request to provide a 100-foot buffer between the development and existing homes on Mayer Drive. If commissioners had denied the variances, the developers would have been able to develop 92 townhouses with no buffer.

Commissioners Rick Avon, Dan DeMarco, David Mikec, Grace Stanko and president Jeremy Shaffer voted for the plan. Jack Betkowski, Steve Korbel and Lana Mazur voted against it, and Pat Mullin was absent.

Advertise with us

“We are clustering the houses in such a way that there would be no townhouses at all on the southern one-third of site,” said architect Steven Victor. Fifty-one percent of the site will remain open space, chiefly because of the amount of red clay beds that would be prone to landslides if disturbed.

There will be two large “estate homes” built on the other end of the property.

Although the property is in an R-1 single-family residential zone, it also sits in the Lowries Run Road Conservation Corridor, an overlay district that allows townhouses to be built in an area where they would not be permitted otherwise.

“Looking at it, it was very obvious to us that clustering in the northwestern quadrant was the only way to develop that property,” Mr. Victor said. “We never studied a single-family plan. It wouldn’t have made any sense.”

Members of the Buckhill Manor Preservation Coalition presented several speakers who rebutted points by representatives of the developer that the townhouses won’t affect the environment or traffic in the area.

Advertise with us

“The soil stability is a major concern for this development,” said Grace Pan, who said she is a soil expert. “The construction greatly increases the danger of landslides in this area.”

David Wingerd, a licensed geologist, said that part of Buckhill Road was closed following Hurricane Ivan in 2004. Two houses were affected by landslides, and one is still vacant.

“In general, the development is being proposed on the top of a hillside. Eighty-four units being put in densely, another development that is being shoehorned into a space with the most houses possible,” he said. “I don’t believe the conditions are prudent for this development as proposed.”

Chris Lane, who lives on Sewickley-Oakmont Road, disputed the traffic study that showed that the development would not increase traffic in the area, saying that he can’t get out of his driveway now.

“I think they are grossly underestimating the traffic the development will have,” he said. “Common sense says that if you have 85 units and 160 cars at rush hour, it is going to have a significant impact on traffic.”

Advertise with us

In other business, commissioners reminded residents that their Oct. 17 meeting will be held at the new public works complex off Cemetery Lane. The building will be open at 4 p.m. for tours, and the meeting will begin at 6:30.

Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.