Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto won’t take another delay of game from the Penguins in redeveloping the former Civic Arena site.
Mr. Peduto urged the team Tuesday to get moving on the 28-acre redevelopment or to give up the rights to the lower Hill District land.
In an interview with reporters, the mayor said he intends to hold the Penguins to the Oct. 21 deadline to start the first phase of a 1,200-unit residential development near Crawford Square.
“I certainly am one of the biggest hockey fans in the city, and I want to see that area developed, but you got to get moving,” he said. “It’s time to get moving.”
Mr. Peduto was reacting to a report in Tuesday’s Post-Gazette based on a March 4 letter of intent in which the Penguins stated they might not be able to start the development this fall because of site contamination, a $5 million financing gap and other issues.
The team tied the contamination in part to the demolition of buildings in the 1950s and said the remediation effort could jeopardize the timetable for the 175-unit first phase of the residential.
Read More
But Mr. Peduto didn’t believe the environmental issues were serious enough to warrant a delay.
“There are environmental concerns on every inch of Pittsburgh. Probably not even Schenley Park doesn’t have some level of environmental concerns. That’s a basic of development. That comes with being a developer, is understanding that that is part of developing in an urban area,” he said.
“There’s no reason that should be a reason for delaying the project.”
The Penguins said the $5 million funding shortfall in the $45 million first phase was created by the requirement to earmark 20 percent of all 1,200 units to eventually be built at the site as affordable.
Under the deal reached with political and Hill leaders, 15 percent of the units are reserved for people making 80 percent of the area median income and 5 percent for those making 60 percent to 70 percent of the area median.
Mr. Peduto said the city has urged the Penguins and their residential developer, St. Louis-based McCormack Baron Salazar, to consider affordable housing tax credits to help fill the gap.
While he did not entirely rule out public subsidies to help close it, he stressed that the city had more pressing needs right now.
“We have an entire city that needs to be rebuilt and right now that area is not the area that has the greatest need in the city. We have an affordable housing crisis in people who can’t afford to stay in their homes and we need to be able to allocate funds toward that,” he said. “We have neighborhoods that haven’t seen any redevelopment for 50 years. We need to invest in them. We can’t just throw all of our money in one project and one development.”
If the Penguins are having trouble getting started in redeveloping the land, it may be an “opportune time” to explore the possibility of buying the rights back from the team, Mr. Peduto said.
The team won the development rights to the publicly owned arena site in the 2007 deal to build Consol Energy Center. “We’re now nine years in. We should be seeing development,” the mayor said.
The mayor has been floating the idea of a buyout of the development rights for nearly a year. He first suggested it after the team was put up for sale last year.
Team officials have said they have no intention of giving up the rights. They declined to comment Tuesday on Mr. Peduto’s statements.
The Penguins did reach a deal with U.S. Steel to build a new headquarters at the site, but that ended up falling through because of the steelmaker’s financial struggles.
As a result, the Penguins have purchased two extensions using $15 million in development credits awarded in the Consol deal to get more time to develop those parcels while they work to find another tenant. They also have the right under their agreement with the city to buy more time to start the residential phase.
Given that, it's unclear what legal authority Mr. Peduto would have to hold them to the October deadline.
While the team has said it would evaluate the use of tax credits to help close the $5 million gap, it has expressed concern that they could change the affordability mix it has agreed to on the units. Mr. Peduto didn’t believe that would be the case.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.