The size of the middle class in the Pittsburgh region is shrinking as is generally the case in the U.S., according to a new study, but it may not call for the same hand-wringing connected to the trend nationally.
The reason: The size of the population in the lower-income tier locally also has been shrinking this century, says the Pew Research Center report released last week. Only the upper-income population grew in the seven-county Pittsburgh metropolitan area between 2000 and 2014, based on data the Pew report used from the American Community Survey.
The report categorized 55 percent of the local population as middle class in 2014, down from 57 percent in 2000, while the middle class nationally shrank from 55 percent to 51 percent. It defined the middle class as a household having between two-thirds and double the median income. Nationally, for a three-person household, that would have meant income between $41,641 and $124,925 in 2014.
“The shrinking of the American middle class is a pervasive phenomenon,” said Rakesh Kochhar, associate research director for Pew and the lead author of the report. “It has increased the polarization in incomes.”
But unlike an increase in both the lower- and upper-income tiers nationally at the expense of middle-income earners, the Pittsburgh area’s lower-income population decreased from 26 percent to 24 percent while upper-income households expanded from 17 percent to 22 percent.

PG graphic: Middle class changes
(Click image for larger version)
Of the 229 metropolitan areas examined in the study, Pittsburgh was one of 67 in which more people moved up the income ladder than down and shrinkage occurred in the number of lower-income households.
“Clearly, you are in one of the better situations,” said Richard Fry, a Pew senior researcher. “Unlike other metro areas where they have had difficulty recovering from a loss of traditional manufacturing, Pittsburgh has gotten that behind it and figured out a way to diversify its economy.”
Laurence Ales, an associate professor of economics at Carnegie Mellon University, said income “polarization” has been a subject of increasing concern for decades in the U.S. and other industrialized countries. The recent history of job growth is in low-skilled and high-skilled sectors of the economy rather than in between, and substantial growth in the percentage of Pittsburghers with college degrees points to what kind of local trend has been taking place.
“Pittsburgh has clearly seen a growth of high-skilled service-sector jobs,” primarily in health care and the high-tech sector, Mr. Ales noted.
Mr. Fry said the middle class was estimated to cover 61 percent of households nationally when Pew began doing such studies in 1970, as opposed to 51 percent currently.
“Each decade, we’ve witnessed this shrinkage of middle-income households,” he said. “There’s this mystique, this self-perception, that the great swath of Americans identify themselves as middle class, but when you try to measure it you get that it’s about half” of households.
William Beaver, a sociology professor at Robert Morris University, said the Pew data is somewhat limiting in defining just the three income categories. A Robert Morris Polling Institute survey released in January 2015 found that 2.6 percent of Americans defined themselves as upper class, 14.4 percent as upper middle class, 39 percent as middle class, 29.9 percent as working class and 9.9 percent as lower class.
Mr. Beaver said the Pew study’s determination that the percentage of local lower-income households had shrunk was interesting, in that “you wouldn’t expect the lower class to have shrunk in the last 14 years, especially after the recession. It’s hard to know why the lower class would have shrunk. Where did those people go?”
The Associated Press contributed. Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.