A Chicago developer won approval for his plans to convert the historic Strip District produce terminal into a hub for retail, offices and apartments Thursday, though he and others conceded that much work remains to be done before the vision can become a reality.
City Urban Redevelopment Authority board members unanimously endorsed the proposal advanced by McCaffery Interests despite concerns about the financing and the impact it could have on the thriving Penn Avenue retail corridor.
The URA will spend the next six months working with McCaffery to finalize financing and other details of the plan, which is estimated to cost as much as $70 million counting the rehabilitation of Smallman Street that officials say is critical to the proposed redevelopment.
“Now is really where the hard work begins,” said Robert Rubinstein, URA acting executive director.
Some two years in the making, the McCaffery plan features 65,100 square feet of retail, most of it facing Smallman and anchored by a “merchant shop” at one end; 57,385 square feet of open office space; 18 live-work apartments totaling 12,925 square feet; and 14,678 square feet of existing commercial.
In addition, the developer is proposing to extend the elevated dock that runs the length of the 1,533-foot-long building by 12 feet to make it easier to walk, create pedestrian passages through the structure at 17th, 18th and 20th streets; and to add 280 parking space on the side facing the Allegheny River.
Read More
Under the proposed deal, the URA, the terminal owner, would enter into a ground lease of up to 99 years with McCaffery for use of the Strip landmark, once a hub for fruit and vegetable wholesalers.
Because of the length of the lease, the redevelopment would be taxable. It would generate an estimated $1 million a year in tax revenue, according to Mr. Rubinstein.
Nonetheless, URA board member Jim Ferlo said he had concerns about the financial viability of the project. He also raised questions about how it would be financed and the amount of public investment needed.
McCaffery expects to put $50 million into the building, said Dan McCaffery, CEO of McCaffery Interests. He added there definitely will be a need for public investment, most of it related to the rehabilitation of Smallman Street to make it more pedestrian and bicyclist friendly.
Public realm improvements likely will total $7 million to $15 million, Mr. Rubinstein said. Possible funding sources could include tax increment financing, state redevelopment capital assistance and perhaps even support from local foundations.
Mr. Ferlo said he also had concerns about the project’s impact on the popular Penn Avenue corridor, with its eclectic blend of food merchants, restaurants and retail vendors. He feared that in creating what he described a new and improved “Whole Foods”-looking development at the produce terminal, “I think we’re going to kill something.”
But Mr. McCaffery said that’s not his intent. He noted the project could have the opposite effect of bringing more people to the Strip to visit merchants on Penn.
“I wouldn’t want to do anything to hurt Penn Avenue. It’s great,” he said.
Mr. Ferlo wasn’t the only one with concerns about the future.
Janet McCall, executive director of the Society for Contemporary Craft, which has occupied the far east end of the terminal for 30 years, told the board she is concerned the redevelopment could end up driving out the group when its lease expires in 2018.
The organization, which has spent $1.5 million upgrading its space over the years, can’t afford to be subjected to soaring rents in the Strip, she said. She pressed the board to make final approval of the project contingent on McCaffery reaching a “reasonable deal” with the group.
Mr. McCaffery said he has every intent of keeping the organization. He noted the financial assumptions for the redevelopment show the group at “roughly the same rent they’re at now.”
“We intend to try to be very reasonable with them,” he said.
Mr. McCaffery said it could take six to nine months to get all financing in place and another 14 to 18 months for construction. The redevelopment could be completed in 24 to 30 months, he said.
The potential retail mix could include everything from shops to pubs to restaurants, as well as a market component at the terminal’s west end. The city also is considering an outdoor public market on that side that could stretch to the 16th Street Bridge.
With the URA board approvals Thursday, Mr. McCaffery now hopes to begin earnestly reaching out to possible tenants.
But he stressed that the key to the overall success of the redevelopment might be the retooling of busy Smallman Street in front of the terminal to make it more inviting and safer for everyone. It can be dangerous to navigate these days, he said.
“We crossed it twice today — and made it,” he joked.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.