With “foodcentric” retail and offices throughout the building, a Chicago developer is ready to go with a plan to bring new life to the Strip District produce terminal.
Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority board members will vote Thursday on whether to accept a $65 million proposal from McCaffery Interests to fill the Strip landmark with retail, offices and 18 live-work apartments.
At the same time, the city is hoping to complement what’s going on inside the building with plans for an outdoor marketplace and possibly food trucks at its western end.
Dan McCaffery, CEO of McCaffery Interests, said he is very happy with the plan, some two years in the making, that will go before the URA board.
“It will be an exciting neighborhood anchor,” he said.
The proposal would be part of a broader plan that would include the rehabilitation of Smallman Street from the terminal to 21st Street, said Kevin Acklin, URA board chairman and chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto. It may include a Market Square-like public plaza near 21st.
Read More
He noted that the goal is to keep the “quirky nature of Smallman” and to foster development on both sides while making it safer and more friendly for pedestrians and bicyclists.

PG graphic: Produce terminal
(Click image for larger version)
Mr. Acklin described the terminal redevelopment as a “destination project” that would add to the Strip’s amenities while complementing the popular Penn Avenue retail corridor.
“It’s a very exciting time. We feel like we have a developer who has put in the effort to listen and has responded and who will continue to listen and respond,” he said.
What will go before the URA board this week is a far cry from what McCaffery first proposed two years ago, which was a plan to convert the terminal into 118 residential units, including 14 live-work lofts; 20,000 square feet of office space; and 35,000 square feet of retail.
Mr. McCaffery said Monday he abandoned that proposal when he determined it would be too expensive.
The new plan will feature about 65,100 square feet of new retail; 57,385 square feet of open office space; 18 live-work apartments totaling 12,925 square feet; and 14,678 square feet of existing commercial.
McCaffery also is proposing to cut pedestrian passages through the terminal at 17th, 18th and 20th streets while maintaining the length and roof line of the old 1,533-foot-long warehouse, once a hub for produce wholesalers. There will be no pass-throughs for vehicles.
“The important thing was to make the project and pedestrian life permeable and we’ve done that,” he said.
Most of the retail will be on the Smallman Street side of the terminal, with office, commercial and residential uses centered on the Allegheny River side, Mr. Acklin said.
The city is hoping the developer will focus on small retail businesses to fill the building. Mr. McCaffery said he was looking at a “pretty exciting tenant mix” but was not more specific.
He acknowledged that he has spoken to representatives of The Kitchen, a trendy restaurant chain based in Colorado that emphasizes community and locally sourced ingredients, and will do so again once he gets control of the building.
Mr. McCaffery said he also supports the city’s idea for an outdoor public market at the Downtown end of the terminal. Mr. Acklin said Mr. Peduto and local foundations are interested in pursuing the initiative.
Under the plan to be discussed Thursday, the URA intends to lease the building to McCaffery for up to 99 years. That will allow it to be taxed under state law. Mr. Acklin said it was important for the city to keep the terminal as a public asset.
The project and the Smallman and 21st Street improvements will be funded through public and private sources, including loans, historic tax credits, state capital assistance and private equity. The city also is considering tax increment financing, Mr. Acklin said.
About $7 million in Smallman renovations are included in the $65 million project cost, he said. The city is planning a public planning process to discuss possible changes to the street.
Before the latest plan emerged, the URA had teamed McCaffery with Pittsburgh-based Rubino Partners to try to work together on a vision for the terminal, but it produced no agreement. McCaffery worked with Pittsburgh Gateways Corp. to come up with the latest proposal.
URA board member Jim Ferlo called the McCaffery-Rubino marriage a “waste of time and money.”
He described the current proposal as a “step forward and two steps back” — a step forward because the URA ditched the McCaffery-Rubino marriage but two steps back “because the financing is more speculative than ever” with loans, a possible TIF, and state and county grants.
Mr. Ferlo said the rehabilitation of Smallman also presented big challenges and could be very costly.
McCaffery was one of three developers to submit proposals for redeveloping the terminal in April 2014 after Mr. Peduto worked out an agreement with the Buncher Co., which held an option to buy the property from the URA, to seek alternatives. The mayor didn’t like Buncher’s plan to raze the western third of the building to extend 17th Street to the river.
Buncher also had proposed a mix of offices, restaurants and retail in redeveloping what would have been left of the terminal.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.