The decision by U.S. Steel to stay in its U.S. Steel Tower offices may have been a blow to the Penguins’ plans to redevelop the former Civic Arena site, but it’s good news for Downtown landlords and perhaps even those seeking to build more office space.
In abandoning a new headquarters at the arena site, the Pittsburgh steelmaker, at least for the time being, will be staying in the 450,000 square feet of space it leases in the building that bears its name on Grant Street.
That should keep the Downtown office market tight, allowing landlords to continue to charge higher rents for their space, according to area real estate experts. Many had fretted after U.S. Steel announced its intent last year to build a headquarters in the lower Hill District that the large block of space it would be leaving Downtown could play havoc with rents and vacancies. Not anymore.
“I think it’s status quo,” said Jonathan Bonime, senior vice president of Fischer and Co., a corporate real estate firm, Downtown. “I don’t think it tightens the market. It prevents the market from loosening.”
The vacancy rate for top-of-the-line Class A space Downtown, which ranges from 6.8 percent to 8.6 percent, remains one of the lowest in decades. The asking rate, at $27 to $28 a square foot, is one of the highest in years.
Had U.S. Steel moved ahead with the new headquarters, it would have been set to vacate U.S. Steel Tower in 2017 when its lease expired. But Kevin Acklin, Mayor Bill Peduto’s chief of staff, said earlier this month that the company told him it had extended its lease by 1½ years.
Read More
If that is true — U.S. Steel hasn’t said — “That’s big,” said Jason Stewart, executive vice president of the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm.
An extension would push the lease expiration to perhaps early 2019 and add more stability to the Downtown market. “It’s no longer a block of space people can depend on coming available or use as leverage against existing property owners,” Mr. Stewart added.
Some believe the U.S. Steel decision could help bolster efforts to build new office towers in or near Downtown.
Oxford Development Co. and Burns & Scalo Real Estate have been marketing new skyscrapers. Highwoods Properties and Alco Parking president Merrill Stabile also have been pitching new office projects at SouthSide Works and on the North Shore.
Gregg Broujos, managing director and founding principal of the Colliers International real estate firm, said such projects, along with the arena site, could be viable alternatives for companies looking for large blocks of space. Mr. Broujos is working with Oxford to try to attract an anchor for a proposed 29-story skyscraper on Smithfield Street, Downtown.
Count Jeffrey Ackerman, managing director of the CBRE real estate firm, as a skeptic.
“I don’t think [the U.S. Steel decision] changes anything. With a new building, they’ll still need an anchor tenant,” he said.
Nonetheless, Gerard McLaughlin, executive managing director of the Newmark Grubb Knight Frank real estate firm, said he would not be surprised if those marketing new office towers try to court U.S. Steel.
The corporation seems to be interested in reducing its footprint. The building it planned at the arena site, at 285,000 square feet, was much smaller than its current space. Oxford had been pursuing U.S. Steel before it settled on the arena site.
Like Mr. Ackerman, he doesn’t see any of the proposed high-rises getting out of the ground any time soon.
While the Downtown market is tight, there’s space available, he said. BNY Mellon is vacating about 600,000 square feet in 525 William Penn Place. Jones Lang LaSalle is leaving the building as well.
There’s also space in One Oxford Centre, the K&L Gates Building, PPG Place, the Koppers Building and the Union Trust Building, he said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.