City planning commission members raised concerns Tuesday about the future of a public park caught up in the plans to redevelop the Penn Plaza apartments in East Liberty.
They pressed representatives of Pennley Park South, the Penn Plaza owner, on their plans to include public open space in the redevelopment, which requires a zoning change that would involve Enright Parklet.
Also Tuesday, the commission heard plans for the proposed $17 million renovation of the Town Place Building at Stanwix Street and Forbes Avenue, Downtown that would include a 40-foot by 75-foot video screen to project images and mesh cladding that would move with the wind.
In East Liberty, Pennley Park has petitioned the commission to change the zoning of Penn Plaza from residential to mixed use, a designation that would affect the park as well and perhaps leave it open to redevelopment.
The proposed change was part of an agreement reached between the city and Pennley Park to help provide for Penn Plaza tenants displaced by the redevelopment and create an affordable housing fund. In the deal, the city agreed to sell Enright to Pennley, with proceeds being used to create a fund to build low-income housing in other parts of the neighborhood.
Commission members raised concerns about the possible loss of the park and wanted assurances that comparable public space would be provided in the redevelopment. Member Paul Gitnik pressed Pennley Park representatives to commit at least 20 percent of the redevelopment to public open space.
Read More
But Jonathan Kamin, Pennley attorney, said it was too early to make any commitment, adding the developer would do what the city required, based on a complicated formula tied to how the land is used. He stressed a “significant portion” of the site would be public open space.
Pennley also may make improvements to another public park located about 150 yards from Enright.
Mr. Kamin said the problem with keeping Enright intact is that would prevent Pennley from following through with a plan to reconnect S. St. Clair Street with Penn Avenue and Eva Street with S. St. Clair.
Mr. Kamin noted that the sale of the parklet to Pennley would need the approval of city council and Mayor Bill Peduto.
The proposed redevelopment would feature about 400 apartments, mainly market rate, and street-level retail. Pennley has committed 50 percent of tax increments from the project to fund affordable housing. It may also do affordable housing at the site in a second phase.
Downtown, Kossman Development Company plans to convert the 12-story Town Place from offices, retail and parking to fully furnished executive apartments, retail and parking. The 63 apartments would be available for short- or long-term stays. There also would be rooftop penthouses, a sport court and hot tub.
“We believe strongly that there is a market for that kind of product,” said Curtis Kossman, president of Kossman Development.
Outside, Kossman plans to wrap most of the Stanwix and Forbes sides with an architectural mesh that will move with the wind. A different colored mesh, anchored so it does not move, will be used for the video screen.
Kossman is hoping one day to display advertising on the screen, now prohibited by city ordinance. For the time being, it intends to use LED lighting to highlight it. It also may display artwork or other images. During the day, the screen will change appearance depending on the amount of sunlight and is transparent enough to see the building behind it.
Nonetheless, some commission members raised concerns, with one saying the screen seemed like a “billboard awaiting some kind of advertising” and another chiming in that it looked like a “blank white slate.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.