The Canadian Fur Co., which two years ago was on the brink of closing, may finally be ending its long run Downtown. Owner Keith Rosenstock said he plans to close the store Jan. 15 — its 97th anniversary.

It’s the second time in two years the upscale store, where clients range from affluent suburbanites to young career women, faces its demise. In December 2013, Mr. Rosenstock sent a letter to 2,500 active customers saying the store would close in January 2014, and it held a retirement sale.

But when his landlord offered to extend his lease two years, the furrier stayed open. Now that lease, which included a tenant non-renewal clause, is expiring. Barring another last-minute reprieve, the store will close its doors for good.

In a bid to stay in business, Mr. Rosenstock, 65, offered the city Urban Redevelopment Authority $1.86 million to buy the John M. Roberts & Son building on Wood Street and its neighbor the Skinny Building — enough to reimburse the URA for what it spent to procure both in 2013 and another $561,000 to defray the cost of facade improvements made.

Advertise with us

The URA plans to hold on to the Roberts building until maybe 2021, when the lease expires to a 7-Eleven convenience store on the first floor and then seek a request for proposals for its reuse.

URA officials offered to lease the vacant upper floors of the building to Mr. Rosenstock for five years, but he didn’t think spending $300,000 to build a showroom and a vault to hold his furs made sense with a lease.

It is the second time he has been foiled in his pursuit of the building. He bid $1.1 million for the Roberts and Skinny buildings in 2012 only to see them sold to the URA for $1.3 million.

He is angered by the latest rejection, complaining that Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto and his administration have turned their back on his repeated attempts to buy the building based on 10 special circumstances.

But Robert Rubinstein, URA acting executive director, and Kevin Acklin, its board chairman and chief of staff to Mr. Peduto, said it’s a “rare exception” for the URA to sell a building through a negotiated sale rather than seeking competitive proposals.

Advertise with us

Mr. Acklin argued that selling the Roberts building now would amount to a bad business move. With the opening of the new PNC headquarters across from the building this week, he sees potential for Wood to become a key retail corridor Downtown.

He said the goal is “to maximize the return to the public for its investment.”

Mr. Rubinstein said the URA offered to help Mr. Rosenstock find another location, and he wasn’t interested. The furrier said he did approach the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation about buying a property on Wood, but it didn’t want to sell.

McKnight Realty Partners, Mr. Rosenstock’s current landlord, also offered the furrier the option to stay, but he declined, said Izzy Rudolph, a McKnight principal. Mr. Rosenstock said the terms were not acceptable.

“Canadian Fur was an important part of the redevelopment of the Heinz 57 Center,” Mr. Rudolph said. “This is truly the end of an era and we wish him well in the future.”

Advertise with us

With his options dwindling, Mr. Rosenstock has resigned himself — again — to closing Canadian Fur, a business started by his great, great uncle and handed down through the family.

The store opened in 1919 at the corner of Fifth Avenue and Wood, where Kashi Jewelers is located, and has moved around. With six employees, it has been at its current location since 2002.

While Mr. Rosenstock will continue to sell online, the decision to close the store is a tough one, he said.

“You have no idea. I have a bad back. I mean there’s a lot of reasons for saying I should retire. But the one thing I can’t get out is that I look at my family and 97 years of work ending. It’s very hard for me to take.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.